Audit records no reply from nuclear regulator on N2.98bn of constituency contracts; Acts gave N925m for a Kano centre 'to prevent nuclear tests in the Sahara Desert'
The Auditor-General's 2024 non-compliance report raises twelve queries on the Nigeria Nuclear Regulatory Authority's 2022 and 2023 accounts, led by N2.98 billion of constituency project contracts with no evidence of verification, and records "No response" to each. Vero Record set them against the authority's lines in the 2022 and 2023 Appropriation Acts. Several of the projects the audit describes match lines in the Acts, among them N925 million each for a monitoring centre at Limanchi in Kano State and a radiology centre at Gyaraugi. Under those projects the auditors found no evidence that N264.24 million of Limanchi equipment or five dialysis machines were supplied. The Acts show the money was voted; the audit questions the evidence for how it was spent.
The 2022 and 2023 Appropriation Acts gave the Nigeria Nuclear Regulatory Authority N925 million for a "West Africa" nuclear and radiation monitoring centre at Limanchi in Kano State, a project both Acts describe as being to prevent nuclear tests in the Sahara Desert. In its report on non-compliance for 2024, the Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation says the authority awarded N399,685,000 of contracts for the centre on 20 November 2023 and found no evidence that items worth N264,244,990 had been supplied. That is one of twelve queries the report raises on the authority's accounts for 2022 and 2023. The largest, N2,977,493,452, covers sixteen constituency project contracts for which the auditors found no evidence of the verification that federal circulars require. Under every one of the twelve, the authority's response is recorded as "No response."
The report is the Auditor-General's 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Volume II. Its section on the authority, on pages 513 to 527, covers the period from 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2023. Each query follows the same form: the rule, what the auditors observed, the risks, the management's response, the auditor's evaluation, and a recommendation that the Director-General account for the sum to the Public Accounts Committees of the National Assembly and "recover and remit to the Treasury". The report attributes each set of anomalies to "weaknesses in the internal control system" at the authority. An audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing. Where the report says there was "no evidence", it means the auditors were not shown the documents; it does not establish that goods were never delivered or work never done. Vero Record set the queries against the authority's own project lines in the 2022 and 2023 Appropriation Acts.
The largest query is headed "Payment of constituency/zonal intervention projects executed without approval from relevant authorities". Under 2017 circulars quoted in the report, agencies award and supervise such projects and raise payment certificates for the Special Duties Office, which "shall verify and ascertain the level of work done and authorize payments". The auditors found that sixteen contracts totalling N2,977,493,452 "were awarded to various contractors for projects and consultancy services under constituency projects", and that there was no evidence the projects were verified or the payments authorised by the Federal Ministry of Special Duties and Inter-Governmental Affairs. The second largest query, N1,427,545,477, concerns contracts awarded to companies "that are related, having common Directors and the same office address", with no evidence of due diligence on the bidders. The report does not list the contracts behind either sum.
The Appropriation Acts list the authority under the Ministry of Petroleum Resources. The 2022 Appropriation Amendment gave it N1,815,188,937 for capital projects. Three of its project lines name a place: N425,000,000 for the "Establishment of West Africa nuclear and radiation monitoring, detection and response center in Limanchi LGA, Kano State to prevent nuclear tests in the Sahara Desert"; N425,000,000 for a "model diagnostic and intervention radiology center" in "Gyaraugi LGA", phase 1; and N255,000,000 for an "intervention to stop the spread of waste containing naturally accrued radioactive materials" from oil and gas exploration in the Niger Delta states. Together they come to N1,105,000,000.
The 2023 Appropriation Act gave the authority N1,803,647,796 for capital projects, and N1,600,000,000 of it sits in four lines: N500,000,000 for the Limanchi centre, now marked "Phase II" and still "to prevent nuclear test in the Sahara Desert"; N500,000,000 for the Gyaraugi radiology centre, described as "Phase I" and ongoing; N400,000,000 for a radiation detection, monitoring and emergency response centre "for the South-South geo-political zone"; and N200,000,000 for an NNRA operating office in Uyo, Akwa Ibom State. Across the two years these seven lines total N2,705,000,000, or 74.7 per cent of the N3,618,836,733 the two Acts gave the authority for capital. The Limanchi centre and the Gyaraugi centre each received N925,000,000.
The Limanchi query is the last in the section, headed "Payment for contract not executed". Two contracts were awarded under one award letter dated 20 November 2023, with a completion period of twelve weeks: N99,867,500 for the centre's laboratory (Lot 6A) and N299,817,500 for the "expansion of building structure" (Lot 6B). They add to N399,685,000, which is 79.9 per cent of that year's N500,000,000 line. The auditors found "no evidence to show that items valued at N264,244,990.00 ... as specified in the Bill of Quantities, were supplied". That is 66.1 per cent of the contract value. On one point the Acts support the authority: the centre was a project the National Assembly funded, and the contracts stay within the line. The query is about proof of delivery, not about whether the money was voted.
The Gyaraugi centre appears in two queries by name. A contract dated 19 December 2022, for N293,128,661.35, covered "dialysis machines, stabilizers, dialysis consumables, and X-ray equipment" for the radiology centre "in Gyaraugi LGA, Kano Phase II". It included a provisional sum of N135,500,228.85, paid for five dialysis machines (SWS 4000A), stabilisers and consumable kits, and the auditors found no evidence those items were supplied; the report adds that the contractor's "core business is in engineering services". A second contract, dated 20 November 2023, was for N474,612,500, which is 94.9 per cent of the 2023 line. The contractor's own priced bill of quantities came to N444,862,766.80, so the award was N29,749,733.20, or 6.7 per cent, above it. The report says the contract sum was paid by a voucher dated 28 December 2023, 38 days after the award letter and inside the twelve-week completion period, "without evidence of verification and authorization" by the Special Duties ministry. The two contracts add to N767,741,161.35, against N925,000,000 appropriated for the centre.
A third query, for N306,649,776, concerns "the purchase and installation of medical equipment and training for C-Arm and Mammography". It cites the same letter reference as the N474,612,500 Gyaraugi contract, NNRA/PROC/CP/23/07/I/327, and the same date, 20 November 2023. It includes N145,000,000 for one C-Arm image intensifier system and N116,000,000 for a mammography machine, for which there was no evidence of supply, and a lump sum of N45,649,776 for training, for which there was no evidence that training took place. The three parts add to N306,649,776. The report does not name a site for this equipment, and it does not say whether the two queries describe one contract or two.
The audit also describes contracts on the subject of the 2022 line against radioactive oil waste. Three contracts dated 25 August 2022 went to two companies for "a stakeholders' workshop in Cross River State to discuss the 2021 findings on the intervention to stop the spread of waste containing Naturally Occurring Radioactive Materials" and for the training of NNRA regulators in Uyo, Port Harcourt and Enugu "on inspection and assessment of affected areas". They were for N84,118,750, N85,462,500 and N82,450,000, which add to N252,031,250, or 98.8 per cent of the N255,000,000 line; the report does not say which line paid them. The Bureau of Public Procurement had allowed restricted tendering on condition that the authority invite more unrelated firms for each lot. The report says it did not, that the bidders were related, and that "the purported financial bids were submitted on 30th August, 2022, after the award of the contracts", five days later.
Two queries concern regional centres. The 2023 line for the South-South zone was N400,000,000; on 5 December 2023 the authority awarded N279,981,233, or 70.0 per cent of it, for radiation detection, monitoring and emergency response centres "at Port-Harcourt and Bayelsa Offices". The auditors found that the selected company was incorporated in December 2021 "with no record of financial activities", that the first and second bidders were related, and that there was no evidence, such as a store receipt voucher, that N40,074,000 of items in the bill of quantities were supplied. In 2022 the Act also carried N182,594,469 for a model radiology centre with no location named. The report records a N181,900,000 contract of 25 August 2022 for such a centre at Brass, Bayelsa State, for which all five bidders were related and a provisional sum of N21,500,000 was not accounted for. The report does not tie either contract to a budget line.
In Uyo the Acts and the audit describe different things. The only Uyo line in either Act is the 2023 provision of N200,000,000 for the "establishment and equipping of Nigerian Nuclear Regulatory Authority (NNRA) operating office in Uyo". The audit records two consultancy contracts, of N99,835,250 (7 December 2023) and N99,750,285 (20 November 2023), "for the training of youths on digital transformation skills and provision of start-up grants for emerging enterprises in Uyo LGA", awarded to firms with no evidence of accreditation by the Nigerian Council for Management Development. Together they come to N199,585,535, which is N414,465 less than the office line. Neither Act has a line under the authority for youth training or business grants, and the report does not say which line the two contracts were charged to.
The documents leave several things open. The twelve query sums add to N6,688,904,707.35, more than the N3,618,836,733 the two Acts gave the authority for capital; either some contracts are counted in more than one query or some were paid from money outside these lines, and the report does not say which. Because it does not list the sixteen constituency contracts, they cannot be matched to the seven site lines. "No response" records that the authority had not answered the auditors when the report was written; it does not show that the documents do not exist. Whether the Public Accounts Committees have since heard the authority is not in these records. In April 2026 the advocacy group SERAP, citing the Auditor-General's previous report, asked the President to investigate smaller queries at the authority for 2021 and 2022, according to Premium Times; Vero Record has not read that report. The authority was not asked for comment before publication.
Neither centre appears by name in the 2025 or the 2026 Appropriation Act; the 2024 Act was not checked. The 2026 Act gives the authority N798,254,781 for capital. Its largest line is N250,000,000 for the "reconstruction of damaged 33KV line from Ossomala to Ogwuikpele, Anambra State", and four more lines, worth N225,459,599, are for solar street lights in Ogbaru in Anambra State and Uburu in Ebonyi State. Those five lines come to N475,459,599, or 59.6 per cent of the regulator's capital allocation for 2026. Whether the Limanchi and Gyaraugi centres were finished, and whether either now operates, is not recorded in any of the documents read for this report.
What this rests on
Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), section on the Nigeria Nuclear Regulatory Authority, Abuja, printed pages 513 to 527 (PDF pages 78 to 92), period 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2023: Issue 1 p.514, Issue 2 p.515, Issue 3 pp.516-517, Issue 6 p.520, Issue 7 p.521, Issue 8 p.522, Issue 9 p.523, Issue 10 pp.524-525, Issue 11 p.526, Issue 12 p.527; all twelve issues record "No response". The scanned report was read page by page from the copy on file (downloaded from oaugf.ng); a page extract is saved with this story. Budget Office of the Federation, 2022 Appropriation Amendment (file "2022 APPROPRIATION AMENDMENT FINAL COPY 4.pdf"), pp.827, 832 and 833. 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Petroleum Resources (five pages), pp.1 and 5. 2025 Appropriation Act as passed (searched for Limanchi and Gyaraugi; NNRA projects on p.1111). 2026 Appropriation Act, PLAC copy, p.1461. 2023 Supplementary Budget Details (searched; the authority does not appear). Arithmetic re-done: 2022 NNRA project lines 50,000,000 x 6 (irradiator, registry, transport consultancy, plant site evaluation, regulatory research, office equipment) + 25,000,000 + 202,594,468 + 182,594,469 + 425,000,000 + 425,000,000 + 255,000,000 = N1,815,188,937, the printed capital total; site lines 425,000,000 + 425,000,000 + 255,000,000 = N1,105,000,000. 2023 lines 45,000,000 + 113,647,796 + 45,000,000 + 400,000,000 + 500,000,000 + 500,000,000 + 200,000,000 = N1,803,647,796, the printed capital total; site lines 400,000,000 + 500,000,000 + 500,000,000 + 200,000,000 = N1,600,000,000. Two-year capital 1,815,188,937 + 1,803,647,796 = N3,618,836,733; site lines 1,105,000,000 + 1,600,000,000 = N2,705,000,000 = 74.7%; N2,977,493,452 / N3,618,836,733 = 82.3%. Limanchi 425,000,000 + 500,000,000 = N925,000,000; Gyaraugi the same. Limanchi lots 99,867,500 + 299,817,500 = N399,685,000; / 500,000,000 = 79.9%; 264,244,990 / 399,685,000 = 66.1%. Gyaraugi 2023: 474,612,500 - 444,862,766.80 = N29,749,733.20 = 6.7% of the bid; 474,612,500 / 500,000,000 = 94.9%; 20 November to 28 December 2023 = 10 + 28 = 38 days; twelve weeks = 84 days, ending 12 February 2024. Gyaraugi 2022: 293,128,661.35 / 425,000,000 = 69.0%; both contracts 293,128,661.35 + 474,612,500 = N767,741,161.35. C-Arm query 145,000,000 + 116,000,000 + 45,649,776 = N306,649,776 (the report writes the mammography figure as N116,000,000.00 but in words as "Sixteen million naira"; only N116m makes the parts add up). NORM 84,118,750 + 85,462,500 + 82,450,000 = N252,031,250 = 98.8% of N255,000,000 (N2,968,750 less); award 25 August, bids 30 August 2022 = 5 days. South-South 279,981,233 / 400,000,000 = 70.0%. Brass 181,900,000 against 182,594,469 (N694,469 less). Uyo 99,835,250 + 99,750,285 = N199,585,535 (N414,465 less than N200,000,000). Twelve query sums 1,427,545,477 + 2,977,493,452 + 252,031,250 + 74,955,320 + 117,176,513 + 306,649,776 + 21,500,000 + 199,585,535 + 474,612,500 + 293,128,661.35 + 279,981,233 + 264,244,990 = N6,688,904,707.35. 2026 NNRA project lines add to N798,254,781; 250,000,000 + 100,000,000 + 100,000,000 + 16,100,000 + 9,359,599 = N475,459,599 = 59.6%; solar lines alone N225,459,599.
What this does not establish
Whether any of the goods and works queried were in fact delivered: the report says there was no evidence, meaning documents were not produced to the auditors, and the authority gave no response. Whether anyone acted unlawfully; an audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing, and nothing here alleges a crime. Which budget lines the contracts were charged to; the report names projects but not budget codes, so the matches between the audit and the Acts rest on project names and places. Which sixteen contracts make up the N2,977,493,452 constituency query, and whether contracts appear in more than one of the twelve queries; the twelve sums cannot be added as distinct money. Whether the N306,649,776 C-Arm and mammography query and the N474,612,500 Gyaraugi query, which cite the same letter reference, describe one contract or two; if two, they would total N781,262,276 against a N500,000,000 line. Where Limanchi and Gyaraugi are; the Acts and the report place both in Kano State, and their exact locations were not checked. How much of each line was released and spent; no release or implementation figures for the authority were obtained. Whether there was a 2022 supplementary provision for the authority; the 2022 Supplementary Appropriation was not checked, and the 2024 Act was not searched. Whether the centres were completed or operate. Whether the National Assembly's Public Accounts Committees have heard the authority on these queries. The earlier queries reported by Premium Times were not checked against that report. The authority was not asked for comment.
What we did ourselves
Read all twelve of the Auditor-General's queries on the authority from the scanned report, rendering only those pages. Downloaded the 2023 Appropriation Act extract for the Ministry of Petroleum Resources and the 2022 Appropriation Amendment, and listed the authority's project lines for both years, re-adding each list to the printed capital totals. Matched each query that names a project or place to the Act line with the same name, and computed the share of each line the queried contracts represent. Counted the days between award letters, bids and payment vouchers. Re-added the parts of every itemised query. Searched the 2023 supplementary budget details and the 2025 and 2026 Acts for the same projects, and read the authority's 2026 project list.
Sources for this report
(A) Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), Nigeria Nuclear Regulatory Authority, Abuja, pp.513-527; Budget Office of the Federation, 2022 Appropriation Amendment, Nigeria Nuclear Regulatory Authority, pp.827, 832-833; 2023 Appropriation Act, Ministry of Petroleum Resources, Nigeria Nuclear Regulatory Authority, pp.1 and 5.
- 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Internal Control Weakness), Vol. II · Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation · 2026
- 2022 Appropriation Amendment (file: 2022 APPROPRIATION AMENDMENT FINAL COPY 4.pdf) · Budget Office of the Federation · 2022
- 2023 Appropriation Act by sector: Federal Ministry of Petroleum Resources · Budget Office of the Federation · January 2023
- 2023 Supplementary Budget Details · Budget Office of the Federation · 2023
- 2025 Appropriation Act as Passed · National Assembly / Budget Office of the Federation · 2025
- 2026 Appropriation Act (copy published by PLAC) · National Assembly of the Federal Republic of Nigeria · April 2026
- SERAP calls for probe of two Nigerian agencies · Premium Times · 12 April 2026
- File:Nigerian Nuclear Regulatory Authority.jpg (cover photograph) · Wikimedia Commons · 29 June 2026
Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.
Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.
Corrections
None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.
