Audit says the Mathematical Centre diverted N53.05m to village head palaces; the 2022 Act lists those palaces under the Centre at N53.13m
The Auditor-General's 2024 report says the National Mathematical Centre in Abuja diverted N53,051,061.00, appropriated in 2023 for cash grants to women in Darazo/Ganjuwa, Bauchi State, to remodelling village heads' palaces, and records no response from the Centre to any of its six queries. Vero Record set the query against the Appropriation Acts. The Centre's 2023 section has no line for the constituency or for cash grants. Its 2022 section, as amended, lists the palaces at N53,125,000, and four of the five contracts the auditors could not locate match lines in its 2022 budget. In 2026 the Centre's capital vote is N16.04bn, 25.65 times its 2023 figure.
The Auditor-General's report on federal bodies for 2024 says the National Mathematical Centre in Sheda, Abuja, took N53,051,061.00 that had been "appropriated in 2023 for the provision of cash grants to women in Darazo/Ganjuwa Federal Constituency, Bauchi State" and "diverted" it to "the remodelling of Village Head Palaces in Gabayan, Nasarawa, and Kariya within the same constituency". The Centre gave no response. Vero Record set the query against the Appropriation Acts for the two years the auditors examined. The Centre's section of the 2023 Act has no line for Darazo/Ganjuwa and no line for cash grants. Its section of the 2022 Act, as amended, has a line headed "Remodeling of village head palaces of Gabciyari, Nassarawa, Kariya, Yali, Ganjuwa, Tauya and Papa in Darazo/Ganjuwa Federal Constituency, Bauchi State", for N53,125,000.
The query is in Volume II of the Auditor-General's 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, pages 494 to 501, and covers the Centre's books from 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2023. It raises six issues: N612,150,068.04 of contracts awarded with no evidence of advertisement, competitive bidding or evaluation; N86,745,250.00 of items written into the bills of engineering measurement and evaluation of three contracts, among them scholarships, per diem, hotel accommodation and meals, with no evidence of how the money was used; N62,997,742.00 paid on a contract for "Strategic Empowerment for Youths and Women Development in Mbo LGA, Akwa Ibom State"; N29,643,500.00 for printing and distributing notebooks and teaching materials in Ebonyi South Senatorial District, with no distribution records; N227,198,751.04 for five works and supply contracts with no evidence of where they were carried out; and N60,051,061.00 of "expenditure not provided for in the Appropriation Act". Under all six issues, the paragraph headed "Management's Response" reads "No response". The six headline figures add to N1,078,786,372.08, but they overlap: the palace contract appears in both the fifth and the sixth issue, so the sum is not a net total.
An audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing. It records what the auditors could not verify from the papers a body produced, and it asks the head of that body to account for the sums to the Public Accounts Committees of the National Assembly and to recover the money and pay it to the Treasury, with sanctions under the Financial Regulations otherwise. Nothing read for this report shows that the committees have yet heard the Centre on these queries. Because the Centre did not answer, the published report carries only the auditors' account.
The fifth issue sets out the five contracts in a table: remodelling of village head palaces in Darazo/Ganjuwa, N53,051,061.00; land perimeter fencing, access drainage, VIP toilets and a gatehouse at the federal college of health and medical technology at Soro, in the same constituency, N84,920,627.07; shops and market stalls in Dabe and Zalanga, N8,484,710.76; solar street lights in Ebonyi South Senatorial District, N38,278,800.00; and solar street lights in Abeokuta South, Ogun State, N42,463,552.21. The five add to N227,198,751.04, as the table says. The auditors write that the projects "were reported as executed and fully paid for", but that their locations "were not specified in any of the supporting documents" and that there was no evidence they were carried out "at identifiable locations".
Each of those contracts matches a line in the Centre's own appropriation. The Budget Office's copy of the 2022 Act as amended, headed "2022 Appropriation Amendment", lists 24 capital lines under the Centre, which add to its capital total of N864,801,955. Four of them are the audited projects: the palaces at N53,125,000, the Soro fence and gatehouse at N85,000,000, the Dabe and Zalanga stalls at N8,500,000 and the Abeokuta South street lights at N42,500,000. Each audited contract is between 99.82 and 99.91 per cent of its line. The fifth contract, the Ebonyi South street lights, matches a 2023 line of N40,000,000. The Acts also name the places that the auditors say the supporting papers did not: the palace line lists seven villages, Gabciyari, Nassarawa, Kariya, Yali, Ganjuwa, Tauya and Papa, where the audit names three.
The Centre's section of the 2023 Act, in the education volume published by the Budget Office, has 17 project lines adding to N625,301,287. Thirteen of them, worth N425,301,287, fund the Centre's own work, among them mathematics olympiads, research in mathematical sciences, a participant hostel and an auditorium. The other four are constituency lines: N40,000,000 for training in mathematics, science and entrepreneurship in Ebonyi South, N20,000,000 for instructional materials there, N40,000,000 for solar street lights there, and N100,000,000 for artificial intelligence training for young adults in Remo Federal Constituency, Ogun State. None names Darazo/Ganjuwa, and none is for cash grants. In the whole 295-page education volume, the only line that names the constituency is N32,000,000 for three classroom blocks at the college of health technology at Soro, under the Universal Basic Education Commission. The 2023 supplementary budget details have no line for the Centre at all.
On these documents, the remodelling of the palaces was not a project outside the Centre's appropriation: the National Assembly wrote it into the Centre's 2022 budget, at a figure N73,939 above the audited contract sum. Whether that 2022 line could still be paid from when the work was paid for depends on payment dates the report does not give. The cash grants for women that the query says the money was taken from could not be found in the Centre's section of either Act, and the report gives no line code or other reference for them. The same holds for the N7,000,000 the query says was appropriated for "grants to students" in the constituency and paid instead to Darazo Ganjuwa Farm and Special Primary School: neither Act lists such a line under the Centre. The auditors may have seen records that explain the difference, such as a line in another body's budget or a later approval, but the report does not print them.
The Mbo contract has no visible line either. Neither the 2022 nor the 2023 section of the Centre's budget mentions Mbo or Akwa Ibom. The report's own figures on that contract also do not add up. It says payments of N31,498,871.07 on 11 September 2023 and N29,316,505.71 on 10 October 2023 total N62,997,742.00, the full contract sum; the two add to N60,815,376.78, which is N2,182,365.22 less. The first payment is, to within 7 kobo, half the contract sum. The recommendation then asks the Centre to account for N62,997,000.00.
The Centre's budget has since grown many times over. The 2026 Appropriation Act gives it N17,634,367,490, of which N16,038,668,345 is capital, 25.65 times its capital in 2023. Of that capital, N15,708,246,462, or 97.94 per cent, is classed under the economic code for research and development. The 104 project lines, which add exactly to the capital total, include N1,000,000,000 each for a "Shanghai integrated model farm" in Sokoto State and in Kwali Area Council, Abuja, N1,000,000,000 for a "collapsible event arena" at the National Children's Park and Zoo in Abuja, and N350,000,000 for "fairly used Hilux vehicles to support the police and vigilante group in Owan Federal Constituency". Darazo/Ganjuwa has two lines again: N70,000,000 to renovate classroom blocks and N140,000,000 for the "construction of lock-up & stalls". The 11 lines whose titles mention mathematics or the Centre by name add to N1,057,354,782, which is 6.59 per cent of the capital. Adding the seven campus lines carried over from the Centre's 2023 list, for its fence, hostel, auditorium, office renovation, store, internet and library, worth N153,321,883, takes the share to 7.55 per cent.
The record supports the Centre on one point the auditors raise. The palaces, the Soro fence, the Dabe and Zalanga stalls and the street lights in Abeokuta South and Ebonyi South were all in the Centre's appropriation: the National Assembly put them, with their places, into the law, and the Acts do not say who proposed them. The record does not help the Centre on the auditors' main point. An Appropriation Act shows that money was authorised, not that palaces were remodelled, a fence built or street lights installed, and the Centre did not answer the auditors when they asked for that evidence.
Put side by side, the documents show a mathematics research centre whose 2022 and 2023 budgets carried village head palaces, market stalls, a college fence and street lights in three states alongside its olympiads and research, and whose 2026 budget carries model farms, an event arena and vehicles for the police and vigilantes. They confirm the Auditor-General's figures for the five contracts. They do not show the 2023 cash grants line from which the query says N53,051,061.00 was diverted; they show a 2022 line, for the same palaces, of N53,125,000.
What this rests on
Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Vol. II, National Mathematical Centre, Abuja, pp.494 to 501 (PDF pp.59 to 66), period 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2023; read from page images, with pp.497, 498, 500 and 501 checked by eye on rendered pages. Budget Office of the Federation, 2022 Appropriation Amendment, National Mathematical Centre, Sheda, pp.1266 to 1268. Budget Office, 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Education volume, National Mathematical Centre, pp.135 and 136, and p.16 (the only Darazo/Ganjuwa line in the volume); 2023 Supplementary Budget Details, all 18 pages searched. 2026 Appropriation Act (PLAC copy), National Mathematical Centre, pp.1995 to 2001. Arithmetic re-done: audit headline figures N612,150,068.04 + N86,745,250.00 + N62,997,742.00 + N29,643,500.00 + N227,198,751.04 + N60,051,061.00 = N1,078,786,372.08 (overlapping, not net). Issue 5 table: N53,051,061.00 + N84,920,627.07 + N8,484,710.76 + N38,278,800.00 + N42,463,552.21 = N227,198,751.04, as printed. Issue 6: N53,051,061.00 + N7,000,000.00 = N60,051,061.00, as printed. Contracts against Act lines: N53,125,000 - N53,051,061.00 = N73,939.00 (99.86%); N85,000,000 - N84,920,627.07 = N79,372.93 (99.91%); N8,500,000 - N8,484,710.76 = N15,289.24 (99.82%); N42,500,000 - N42,463,552.21 = N36,447.79 (99.91%); 2023 line N40,000,000 - N38,278,800.00 = N1,721,200.00 (95.70%). Darazo/Ganjuwa: three 2022 lines N8,500,000 + N85,000,000 + N53,125,000 = N146,625,000; matching contracts N53,051,061.00 + N84,920,627.07 + N8,484,710.76 = N146,456,398.83. Issue 3: N31,498,871.07 + N29,316,505.71 = N60,815,376.78, against N62,997,742.00 printed, a difference of N2,182,365.22; N31,498,871.07 x 2 = N62,997,742.14. Issue 4: N23,714,800.00 + N5,028,700.00 = N28,743,500.00, as printed, against a contract of N29,643,500.00. 2022 Centre: N686,216,054 + N104,773,058 + N864,801,955 = N1,655,791,067; 24 capital lines add to N864,801,955. 2023 Centre: N793,888,885 + N111,601,842 + N625,301,287 = N1,530,792,014; 17 capital lines add to N625,301,287, of which 13 own lines N425,301,287 and four constituency lines N40,000,000 + N20,000,000 + N40,000,000 + N100,000,000 = N200,000,000. 2026 Centre: N1,223,563,904 + N372,135,241 + N16,038,668,345 = N17,634,367,490; 104 capital lines add to N16,038,668,345; research and development code N15,708,246,462 / N16,038,668,345 = 97.94%; 11 lines naming mathematics or the Centre N1,057,354,782 / N16,038,668,345 = 6.59%; seven carried-over campus lines N70,000,000 + N9,800,000 + N7,000,000 + N21,021,883 + N21,000,000 + N14,000,000 + N10,500,000 = N153,321,883, and (N1,057,354,782 + N153,321,883) = N1,210,676,665 / N16,038,668,345 = 7.55%; N16,038,668,345 / N625,301,287 = 25.65.
What this does not establish
Which year's appropriation the palace contract, or any of the other four contracts, was actually charged to; the report gives no dates or voucher numbers for the five contracts in Issue 5. Whether a line for cash grants to women, or grants to students, in Darazo/Ganjuwa exists in another body's 2023 budget: only the 2023 education volume and the 2023 supplementary details were searched. Why the report describes the money as appropriated in 2023. Whether, and until when, 2022 capital lines could still be paid from in 2023: the extension Acts were not read. Whether the original 2022 Act, before amendment, carried the same lines; the amended version published by the Budget Office was used. Whether the palaces were remodelled, the fence and stalls built or the street lights installed; no site was visited. Why the two Mbo payments add to N2,182,365.22 less than the total the report gives. Who proposed the constituency lines; the Acts do not say. Whether the Centre has answered the auditors or the Public Accounts Committees since the report was published. The N612,150,068.04 of contracts in Issue 1 is not itemised in the report. Nothing in this report suggests that any person committed a crime.
What we did ourselves
Read the Auditor-General's six queries on the National Mathematical Centre from the page images and re-added every table and payment pair. Downloaded the Centre's sections of the 2022 Act as amended and the 2023 Act, and the 2023 supplementary budget details, from the Budget Office, matched each audited contract to its appropriation line by description and amount, and searched the whole 2023 education volume for any line naming Darazo/Ganjuwa or cash grants. Found that the palaces the query calls a diversion are a 2022 appropriation line for the Centre at N53,125,000, and that the report's two payments on the Mbo contract do not add to the total it prints. Parsed all 104 capital lines of the Centre's 2026 allocation and checked them against its capital total.
Sources for this report
(A) Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Internal Control Weakness), Vol. II, National Mathematical Centre, Abuja, pp.494 to 501; Budget Office of the Federation, 2022 Appropriation Amendment, pp.1267 and 1268, and 2023 Appropriation Act, Federal Ministry of Education volume, p.136; 2026 Appropriation Act, pp.1995 to 2001.
- 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Internal Control Weakness), Vol. II · Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation · 2026
- 2022 Appropriation Amendment (2022 Appropriation Amended) · Budget Office of the Federation · 2022
- 2023 Appropriation Act by sector: Federal Ministry of Education · Budget Office of the Federation · 2023
- 2023 Supplementary Budget Details · Budget Office of the Federation · 2023
- 2026 Appropriation Act (copy published by PLAC) · National Assembly of the Federal Republic of Nigeria · April 2026
- File:Tranquility at Gubi Dam Firo Bauchi State.jpg · Wikimedia Commons (Martemmedia, CC BY 4.0) · 21 March 2024
Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.
Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.
Corrections
None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.
