Audit says N3.51bn went on an Epe bridge outside the agriculture ministry's budget; the ministry's 2021 line for that sum reads "road and bridge"
The Auditor-General's 2024 report says the Federal Ministry of Agriculture paid N3,454,528,824.71 on a N10,543,692,694.99 contract for the Ketu-Itoikin road in Epe, Lagos State, against certified work of N1,993,324,737.69, and that N3,509,183,674.00 meant for the road was diverted to a bridge outside "the Ministry's budget". The ministry's 2021 approved budget has a line for exactly N3,509,183,674, and its title is "Completion of Epe - Ketu - Itoikin road and bridge construction work, Lagos". The ministry gave no response to this query or to the eight others in its section of the report. An audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing.
The Auditor-General for the Federation says N3,509,183,674.00 of project funds "earmarked for road construction" on the Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Food Security's Ketu-Itoikin road in Epe, Lagos State, was diverted to build a bridge that was not in the approved scope, the priced bill of quantities or "the Ministry's budget". The ministry's budget for 2021, as published by the Budget Office of the Federation, has a line under the ministry's headquarters for exactly that sum, N3,509,183,674, and the line names a bridge: "Completion of Epe - Ketu - Itoikin road and bridge construction work, Lagos". Vero Record set the audit report against that budget line and the following year's. The audit report does not mention the budget line, and the ministry, which did not answer the audit query, has not explained the difference.
The query is Issue 8 in the ministry's section of the Auditor-General's 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Volume II (printed pages 647 to 659). The section covers the period from 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2021, when the ministry was called the Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, although the auditors inspected the road site in November 2024. It lists nine issues. Under "Management's Response" every one of the nine reads "No response", and the report says the findings "remain valid until the Management implements the recommendations". An audit query records the Auditor-General's view that rules were not followed and is addressed to the Public Accounts Committees of the National Assembly. It is not a finding of fraud or theft, and no court has ruled on any of it.
According to the report (page 655), the contract "for the completion of Ketu-Itoikin Road Project" was awarded to a company for N10,543,692,694.99. The ministry's own Eligibility Assessment Report, the auditors write, showed that the company lacked the financial capacity for a project of that size, with an annual turnover of N1.32 billion and a N4 billion credit facility, "representing only 37.94 percent of the project value". That percentage checks: N4 billion divided by N10,543,692,694.99 is 37.94 per cent. Another shortlisted firm, Visible Construction Limited, had a turnover of N10.18 billion, which the report calls 97 per cent of the project cost (96.55 per cent on the contract sum). The report says the ministry chose the weaker company and recommended it to the Bureau of Public Procurement, which issued a certificate of no objection "without adequately validating the firm's capacity". It does not name the company that won.
When the auditors went to the site in November 2024, the report says (page 656), the contractor had left it. They describe "partially cleared earth, exposed reinforcement bars, scattered construction debris, and an absence of machinery or workforce", consistent with an Interim Job Completion Certificate dated 12 July 2023 that "confirmed only 18.89 percent completion". The site had been abandoned, the report says, "more than eight (8) months after the project's twenty four (24) months completion deadline had elapsed".
On page 657 the auditors set payments against work done. The ministry disbursed N3,454,528,824.71 to the contractor, while the certified value of work completed was N1,993,324,737.69. The difference, N1,461,204,087.02, is what the report calls "an estimated value-for-money loss", and Vero Record's subtraction gives the same figure to the kobo. The report describes the payment as "32.67 percent of the contract sum"; dividing N3,454,528,824.71 by N10,543,692,694.99 gives 32.76 per cent, so two digits appear to have been transposed. The certified work is 18.91 per cent of the contract sum by the same division; the report's 18.89 per cent is the figure on the completion certificate. The ministry is asked to account for the N3,454,528,824.71 and to recover and remit N1,461,204,087.02 to the Treasury.
The bridge is item iii of the same issue (page 656). It reads: "N3,509,183,674.00 of project funds earmarked for road construction was diverted to construct a bridge not included in the approved scope, the priced Bill of Engineering Measurement and Evaluation (BEME), or the Ministry's budget. No variation approval, budget reallocation, or justification accompanied this diversion." Figure 3 on page 657, headed "Present Status of Unauthorized Bridge Construction", shows a bridge over water and a project signboard. As far as the printed photograph can be read, the board's top panels name the client as the Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development and the project as "Construction of Epe-Ketu-Itoikin Bridge/Road in Lagos State".
The Budget Office of the Federation published the 2021 FGN Approved Budget Details on 31 December 2020, as a file named "2021 APPROPRIATION ACT.pdf" whose pages carry the running head "2021 Appropriation Bill". On page 347, under code 0215001001, Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development headquarters, line ERGP554002022 reads "Completion of Epe - Ketu - Itoikin road and bridge construction work, Lagos", marked as a new project, with N3,509,183,674. It is listed among dozens of constituency-style projects placed under the headquarters, from fish markets in Taraba to street lights in Zamfara. The amount matches, to the naira, the sum the audit says was taken from the road and put into the bridge.
The project was funded again the next year. The Budget Office's MDAs Approved 2022 Budget Details, published as "2022 Budget As Passed for PRINTING", list on page 425, under the same headquarters code, line ERGP202201260, "Ongoing Epe - Ketu - Itoikin road, Lagos", with N4,000,000,000, followed by two lines of N500,000,000 each for solar street lights on the "Epe - Ketu road" and the "Ketu - Itoikin express road section B". The two road lines add up to N3,509,183,674 + N4,000,000,000 = N7,509,183,674, or 71.22 per cent of the contract sum. An appropriation is permission to spend, not money released, and neither budget document shows how much was released in either year. The N3,454,528,824.71 the audit says was paid is less than half of the two years' road provisions.
Read together, the two records agree on three things: there was a bridge, it belonged to the Epe-Ketu-Itoikin project, and the sum of N3,509,183,674 belonged to that project. They disagree on authority. The audit says the bridge was outside "the Ministry's budget" and that the money was "earmarked for road construction"; the 2021 budget line provides that same sum for "road and bridge construction work". Both may be true in different senses. The audit may be measuring against the contract's approved scope and priced bill of quantities, which Vero Record has not seen and which may not have included a bridge, rather than against the title of the budget line. The report does not cite the budget line, and it does not say where else the N3,509,183,674 figure comes from.
The report's own figures leave one sum unexplained. The N3,509,183,674.00 it says was diverted to the bridge is N54,654,849.29 more than the N3,454,528,824.71 it says the ministry paid the contractor in total (N3,509,183,674.00 minus N3,454,528,824.71). If the bridge figure is the 2021 appropriation rather than an amount actually paid, that would account for the gap, but the report does not say so, and the documents read for this article do not show how much of the money paid went on the bridge and how much on the road.
The ministry also gave no response to the other eight queries in its section. Under Issue 2 (page 648), the Bureau of Public Procurement cut 14 seedling contract estimates from N2,228,926,150.00 to N1,892,175,664.68, but the ministry presented N2,130,702,006.03 to the Federal Executive Council, N238,526,341.35 more than the bureau certified; the subtraction checks. Issue 9 (page 658) records 14 payments totalling N2,164,702,006.78 to research institutes and companies for seeds and planting materials, from which N53,635,814.66 was deducted as 2.5 per cent "Project Administrative Fees" with no account disclosed; 2.5 per cent of N2,164,702,006.78 would be N54,117,550.17, and the report does not explain the difference. Under Issue 6 (page 653), the ministry's field officers told the auditors that the choice of farmers to receive N280,652,830.00 of seeds from the Institute of Agricultural Research, Samaru, "was influenced by Senators and members of the House of Representatives", and the ministry kept no record of who received what.
The documents do not establish that anyone acted dishonestly, and the 2021 budget line is evidence on the ministry's side: a bridge on this road was in a budget the National Assembly passed. What the ministry has not done, on the record, is answer the Auditor-General. The report does not name the contractor; the lower panels of the signboard in its photograph carry further names but are only partly legible at the resolution printed, and Vero Record has not relied on them. Text searches of the 2025 Appropriation Act as passed and of the 2026 Act found no line naming the Epe-Ketu-Itoikin road; the Itoikin lines in both are Works ministry lines for the separate Ikorodu-Itoikin road.
What this rests on
Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Vol. II, section on the Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Food Security, printed pages 647 to 659 (PDF pages 212 to 224; scanned, read from page images and OCR of only those pages): Issue 8 on pp.655 to 658, Issues 2, 6 and 9 on pp.648, 653 and 658. Budget Office of the Federation, 2021 FGN Approved Budget Details (file "2021 APPROPRIATION ACT.pdf", 33,736,653 bytes, published 31 December 2020), p.347, line ERGP554002022 under code 0215001001. Budget Office, MDAs Approved 2022 Budget Details (file "2022 Budget As Passed for PRINTING Final Copy 2.pdf", 33,399,548 bytes), p.425, lines ERGP202201260, ERGP202201261 and ERGP202201262 under code 0215001001. 2025 Appropriation Act as passed and 2026 Appropriation Act, searched by text for "Itoikin" and "Ketu". All files were already on disk from earlier Vero Record work; their sizes were matched against the Budget Office download headers on 9 November 2026. Arithmetic re-done: N3,454,528,824.71 - N1,993,324,737.69 = N1,461,204,087.02 (matches the report); N3,454,528,824.71 / N10,543,692,694.99 = 32.76% (report prints 32.67%); N1,993,324,737.69 / N10,543,692,694.99 = 18.91% (report gives 18.89% from the 12 July 2023 certificate); N4,000,000,000 / N10,543,692,694.99 = 37.94% (matches); N10.18bn / N10,543,692,694.99 = 96.55% (report: 97%); N3,509,183,674.00 - N3,454,528,824.71 = N54,654,849.29; N3,509,183,674 + N4,000,000,000 = N7,509,183,674, which is 71.22% of N10,543,692,694.99 (adding the two N500,000,000 street-light lines gives N8,509,183,674); N2,130,702,006.03 - N1,892,175,664.68 = N238,526,341.35 (matches); N2,228,926,150.00 - N1,892,175,664.68 = N336,750,485.32 (the bureau's cut); N2,164,702,006.78 x 2.5% = N54,117,550.17 against N53,635,814.66 printed; N2,164,702,006.78 - N2,130,702,006.03 = N34,000,000.75. Nine issues counted in the section, each with "No response".
What this does not establish
Whether the bridge in the audit's photograph is the bridge named in the 2021 budget line; why the audit says the bridge was outside the ministry's budget when the 2021 line provides the same sum for "road and bridge construction work"; what the contract's approved scope and priced bill of quantities contained (Vero Record has not seen the contract, the BEME, the Eligibility Assessment Report or the 12 July 2023 completion certificate); how much of the 2021 and 2022 provisions was actually released; why the sum said to be diverted is N54,654,849.29 larger than the total paid; who the contractor is (the report does not name it and the signboard in its photograph is only partly legible); when the contract was signed and who in the ministry approved the award; the state of the site since November 2024. The 2023 and 2024 Appropriation Acts were not searched for later lines. The 2021 and 2022 Budget Office files carry "Appropriation Bill" in their page heads although the Budget Office publishes them as the approved budget details; the 2021 supplementary budget and the 2022 amendment were not checked. The ministry's side is unknown because it gave no response to the auditors. Nothing in the documents shows that any named person committed an offence, and no court has made any finding.
What we did ourselves
Read the ministry's nine audit queries from the scanned report page by page and counted the responses. Searched the Budget Office's 2020 to 2022 budget detail files and the 2025 and 2026 Acts for the Epe-Ketu-Itoikin road, found the 2021 headquarters line whose amount equals the sum the audit says was diverted, and the 2022 line that funded the same road again. Matched the file sizes against the Budget Office's download headers. Re-did every percentage and subtraction in the audit item, and found the 32.67 per cent that should read 32.76 per cent, the N54,654,849.29 by which the bridge sum exceeds total payments, and the 2.5 per cent fee that does not match its own base.
Sources for this report
(A) Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Vol. II, Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Food Security, Issue 8 (pp.655 to 658); Budget Office of the Federation, 2021 FGN Approved Budget Details, p.347, and MDAs Approved 2022 Budget Details, p.425, Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development headquarters (code 0215001001).
- 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Internal Control Weakness), Vol. II · Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation · 17 July 2026 (transmittal letter)
- 2021 FGN Approved Budget Details (file: 2021 APPROPRIATION ACT.pdf) · Budget Office of the Federation · 31 December 2020
- MDAs Approved 2022 Budget Details (file: 2022 Budget As Passed for PRINTING Final Copy 2.pdf) · Budget Office of the Federation · January 2022
- 2025 Appropriation Act as Passed · National Assembly / Budget Office of the Federation · 2025
- 2026 Appropriation Act (copy published by PLAC) · National Assembly of the Federal Republic of Nigeria · April 2026
- Parked Canoe in the river waiting for passengers, in Epe of Lagos State (cover photograph) · Wikimedia Commons · 31 July 2022
Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.
Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.
Corrections
None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.
