SMEDAN awarded N440m of OLOP grants through microfinance banks, the whole of its 2023 budget line; auditors were shown no list of who got them
The Auditor-General's 2024 non-compliance report raises eight queries worth N1.97 billion on the Small and Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria's 2023 accounts. The first is N440 million of grants for "One Local Government One Product" routed through microfinance banks, the exact sum the 2023 Appropriation Act gave the programme, with no list of beneficiaries shown to the auditors. The largest, N627.36 million of store items the auditors found were not entered in the stores ledger, the agency says relates mostly to constituency projects, whose items are handed over on delivery to the "Member/Senator or his designated representative". The same Act put 73.4 per cent of SMEDAN's N17.54 billion capital vote in lines that name particular places, among them a N500 million police station.
The 2023 Appropriation Act gave the Small and Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria (SMEDAN) N440,000,000 for a programme called "One Local Government One Product (OLOP)". In its report on non-compliance for 2024, the Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation says the agency awarded contracts totalling exactly N440,000,000 under the programme to "various Microfinance Banks (MFBs) for distribution as grants" to cooperative societies. The auditors say they were not given a consolidated list of the cooperatives and beneficiaries, nor the banks' reports on how the grants were disbursed, nor evidence of how the banks were chosen, nor the basis for an administrative fee of 8 per cent that the banks charged. SMEDAN replied that due process was followed. The query is one of eight on the agency's 2023 accounts, which together come to N1,967,239,964.81.
The report is the Auditor-General's 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Volume II. Its section on SMEDAN, on printed pages 718 to 730, covers 1 January to 31 December 2023. Each query sets out the rule, what the auditors observed, the risks, the management's response, the auditor's evaluation, and a recommendation that the Director-General account for the sum to the Public Accounts Committees of the National Assembly and "recover and remit to the Treasury". An audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing. Where the report says there was "no evidence" or that a document "was not provided", it means the auditors were not shown it; it does not establish that money was lost. SMEDAN answered all eight queries, and in several replies says it attached the missing documents as appendices. The auditors judged every reply "unsatisfactory" and kept the findings open. Vero Record set the queries against SMEDAN's lines in the 2023 Appropriation Act.
Under the OLOP query, headed "Violation of due process in award of contracts", the auditors list six observations: the awards themselves; no evidence of advertisement, competitive bidding or evaluation in choosing the banks; no consolidated list of cooperative societies and beneficiaries; no evidence that selected cooperatives were sensitised or that a needs assessment was done "as contained in the Agreement"; no basis given for the 8 per cent fee; and no disbursement reports from the banks. The report does not name the banks, say how many cooperatives were meant to benefit, or say how much reached them. If the 8 per cent were charged on the whole N440,000,000 it would come to N35,200,000; the report does not say on what base it was charged. The auditors' text calls the programme "One Local Government One Project"; the Act and SMEDAN's reply call it "One Local Government One Product".
On this query the Act supports SMEDAN on one point: the National Assembly voted the money for this programme, and the awards the auditors describe equal the line and go no higher. The Act lists OLOP at N440,000,000, project code ERGP3114955, among SMEDAN's capital projects for 2023. SMEDAN's reply describes the scheme: "selected cooperative societies (one per senatorial district) will be supported to acquire industrial machines, work space, power generating sets and working capital". It says it placed a notice-board advert inviting microfinance banks to express interest, evaluated the submissions, and allocated qualifying banks to senatorial districts to pay out to cooperatives "that were earlier selected", and it attached the advert as Appendix I. The report does not cite budget codes, so the match between the awards and the line rests on the programme's name, the year and the amount.
The Act gave SMEDAN N18,467,632,505 for 2023: N718,067,048 for personnel, N206,542,073 for overheads and N17,543,023,384 for capital, which is 95.0 per cent of the total. The capital is spread over 159 project lines, and OLOP is 2.5 per cent of it. Forty-four lines, worth N4,662,697,724, name no place; the largest are N1,325,000,000 to revitalise industrial development centres, N830,000,000 for a conditional grant scheme and N540,000,000 for a national business skills initiative. The other 115 lines, worth N12,880,325,660 or 73.4 per cent of the capital, each name a particular place: a state, zone, senatorial district, federal constituency, local government area, community or road.
Many of those 115 lines are far from small-business support. They include N500,000,000 for the "provision of police station, police quarters and patrol van" in Na Banje community in Kafur Local Government Area of Katsina State; N500,000,000 for the "completion of Ungwan Iliya/Bagudu Kwantakwaran Takwaram-Tsiga-I road"; N300,000,000 for hospital equipment, an ambulance van and a generator in Na-Banue community in Kafur; N100,000,000 for "medicine and medicaments in Kebbi State"; and N100,000,000 for "building of houses for the poor". Five lines of N400,000,000 each, N2,000,000,000 in all, are for training in Gombe Central Senatorial District, under titles such as "Business sensitization training in development training". The audit does not examine any of these lines.
The largest query concerns stores. The auditors found payments of N627,363,914.81 "for the procurement of store items between January, 2023 and December, 2023", and that some of the items, "including laptops, HP LaserJet printers, office furniture and equipment", were not supported by store receipt vouchers or taken on ledger charge. SMEDAN's reply says: "Majority of the store items in question relates to constituency projects that were embedded in to our Capital projects for a given year." Items are delivered "at the Constituency as stated in the award letter", and "Upon delivery, it will be handed over to Member/Senator or his designated representative"; the receipt and issue vouchers are filled in after that, and "the store items are not delivered to the Head Office but rather to the designated locations in the constituency." The report does not list the items or the constituencies, and it does not say which budget lines paid for them.
One query names a place in Gombe Central. The auditors say N47,500,000 was paid by a voucher dated 13 October 2023 to a company "for the provision of skill acquisition training in selected wards of Akko in Gombe Central Senatorial District", and that the tax clearance certificate on file covered 2019, 2020 and 2021, not the year of the award. SMEDAN replied that the wrong certificate had been attached to the voucher and that the current one, for 2020 to 2022, had been retrieved from the company's profile. The report does not say which budget line paid. The 2023 Act's five Gombe Central training lines, worth N2,000,000,000, are the only SMEDAN lines that name that senatorial district.
A third query, for N332,500,000, concerns a contract "for the construction of a youth centre with accommodation" awarded on 1 September 2023, with an agreement signed three days later, on 4 September, that set no completion date. SMEDAN replied that the contract went to African Plus Limited and "was duly executed and completed". The report does not say where the centre is. The 2023 Act has two SMEDAN youth centre lines: N113,000,000 for a youth centre in Lagos East Senatorial District, which is smaller than the contract, and N350,000,000 for the "construction of youth center with accommodation in Chatan South East geopoitical zone", as printed. The contract is 95.0 per cent of that second line, N17,500,000 below it. Vero Record could not identify a place called Chatan. On this query the records are consistent with SMEDAN: the contract fits within a line of the same description, and the auditors' objection is to the missing completion date, not to delivery.
The other queries are smaller. N346,581,300 of cash advances had not been retired; SMEDAN says programme funds came in tranches, that the 2023 budget year was extended to June 2024 and then to December 2024, and that the advances are now fully retired, with vouchers attached. N99,794,750 was paid for monitoring exercises without monitoring reports; SMEDAN says the sum was travel costs for staff sent to monitor training run by consultants, and that monitors write reports at the end of each programme. N60,000,000 went to two contractors, N30,000,000 each, on a voucher dated 3 October 2023 for needs assessments in the North and South, with no evidence of bidding; SMEDAN attached a needs assessment report. The last, N13,500,000, is the value the agency itself put on eight vehicles it classed as unserviceable, with no board of survey convened. The eight sums add to N1,967,239,964.81; the stores and OLOP queries make up N1,067,363,914.81 of it.
SMEDAN's budget has since grown. The 2026 Appropriation Act gives the agency N37,194,682,029, of which N35,479,142,916 is capital, a little over twice the 2023 capital vote. OLOP is still there, under the same code, at N350,000,000. The first four lines of the agency's 2026 project list are all for solar street lights: in Gombe North Senatorial District, in Sokoto, Zamfara, Kebbi, Oyo, Osun and Ogun States, at Banye in Charanchi Local Government Area of Katsina State, and in the Ado/Okpokwu/Ogbadibo federal constituency.
The documents leave a good deal open. They do not show whether any OLOP grant reached a cooperative, how many cooperatives were chosen, or which microfinance banks were used. They do not show what was bought with the N627.36 million, where it went or who received it, beyond SMEDAN's own description. "Not provided" and "no evidence" record what the auditors were shown when they examined the accounts; SMEDAN says it has since supplied some of the documents, and the report does not say whether the auditors have seen them. Whether the National Assembly's Public Accounts Committees have taken up the queries is not in these records. Nothing in the documents establishes that anyone acted unlawfully. SMEDAN was not asked for comment before publication.
What this rests on
Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), section on the Small & Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria, Abuja, printed pages 718 to 730 (PDF pages 283 to 295), period 1 January to 31 December 2023: Issue 1 (OLOP, N440,000,000.00) pp.718-720; Issue 2 (Akko training, N47,500,000.00) pp.720-721; Issue 3 (youth centre, N332,500,000.00; the heading misprints it as N332,500,00.00, while the text and recommendation read N332,500,000.00) pp.721-723; Issue 4 (needs assessment, N60,000,000.00) pp.723-724; Issue 5 (cash advances, N346,581,300.00) pp.724-725; Issue 6 (stores, N627,363,914.81) pp.725-726; Issue 7 (monitoring, N99,794,750.00) pp.727-728; Issue 8 (vehicles, N13,500,000.00) pp.728-730. The scanned report was read page by page from the copy on file (downloaded from oaugf.ng); a 13-page extract is saved with this story. 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment (Budget Office of the Federation, 20 pages), downloaded 13 November 2026: summary p.1; SMEDAN totals and project list pp.13-17 (OLOP p.13; Kafur police station p.14; Gombe Central lines and Lagos East youth centre p.15; Kafur hospital equipment, road and houses lines p.16; youth center with accommodation p.17). 2026 Appropriation Act (PLAC copy): SMEDAN totals and first project lines p.962, OLOP p.966; extract saved. Arithmetic re-done: queries 440,000,000 + 47,500,000 + 332,500,000 + 60,000,000 + 346,581,300 + 627,363,914.81 + 99,794,750 + 13,500,000 = N1,967,239,964.81; stores plus OLOP 627,363,914.81 + 440,000,000 = N1,067,363,914.81. SMEDAN 2023: 718,067,048 + 206,542,073 + 17,543,023,384 = N18,467,632,505 (the printed total); capital share 17,543,023,384 / 18,467,632,505 = 95.0%. The 159 project lines re-add to N17,543,023,384, the printed capital total; the 115 lines naming a place add to N12,880,325,660 (73.4%) and the 44 other lines, OLOP included, to N4,662,697,724; 12,880,325,660 + 4,662,697,724 = 17,543,023,384. OLOP 440,000,000 / 17,543,023,384 = 2.5%. Gombe Central 5 x 400,000,000 = N2,000,000,000. 8% of 440,000,000 = N35,200,000. Youth centre 332,500,000 / 350,000,000 = 95.0%; 350,000,000 - 332,500,000 = N17,500,000; award 1 September to agreement 4 September 2023 = 3 days. Needs assessment 2 x 30,000,000 = N60,000,000. 2026: 35,479,142,916 / 17,543,023,384 = 2.02 times.
What this does not establish
Whether any OLOP grant reached a cooperative, how many cooperatives were chosen, which microfinance banks were used, and how the 8 per cent fee was calculated; the report gives none of these. That the N440,000,000 of awards were charged to the OLOP line in the 2023 Act: the report cites no budget codes, so the match rests on the programme name, the year and the amount. What the N627,363,914.81 of store items were, where they were delivered and who received them, beyond SMEDAN's own reply. Which budget lines paid the Akko training, the youth centre and the monitoring trips; the matches in this report rest on descriptions. Where the youth centre is and whether it was completed: SMEDAN says it was; the Act's text names "Chatan", which Vero Record could not identify. How much of SMEDAN's 2023 capital was released and spent; no release or implementation figures were obtained, and the 2023 supplementary budget and the 2024 and 2025 Acts were not checked for SMEDAN. Whether the auditors have since reviewed the appendices SMEDAN says it attached, and whether the Public Accounts Committees have heard the agency. Who proposed the place-named lines; the Act does not say. Nothing here alleges a crime, and an audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing. SMEDAN was not asked for comment.
What we did ourselves
Read SMEDAN's eight queries from the scanned audit report, rendering only those pages. Downloaded the 2023 Appropriation Act file for the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment, listed all 159 of SMEDAN's capital project lines and re-added them to the printed capital total, then separated the 115 lines that name a place from the 44 that do not. Matched the OLOP query to the OLOP line by name, year and amount, the Akko training query to the Gombe Central lines, and the youth centre query to the only youth centre line large enough to hold it, computing the share each represents. Re-added the eight query sums. Read SMEDAN's 2026 totals and OLOP line in the 2026 Act.
Sources for this report
(A) Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), Small & Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria, Abuja, pp.718-730; 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment, SMEDAN - H/QTRS, pp.1 and 13-17; 2026 Appropriation Act, SMEDAN - H/QTRS, pp.962 and 966.
- 2024 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Internal Control Weakness), Vol. II · Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation · 2026
- 2023 Appropriation Act by sector: Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment · Budget Office of the Federation · January 2023
- 2026 Appropriation Act (copy published by PLAC) · National Assembly of the Federal Republic of Nigeria · April 2026
- File:Offices in Kumo Akko Local Government Area Gombe State. 08.jpg (cover photograph) · Wikimedia Commons · 29 December 2022
Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.
Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.
Corrections
None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.
