Every claim graded  ·  No advertising  ·  Corrections published in place
Vero Record

Reporting and documentary investigation from Nigeria. What the paper says, and what it does not.

Accountability  / 

Police bought 41 vehicles for N3.24bn in 2023 and had insured none, auditors say; that year's Appropriation Act gave the force N394.04m for premiums

The Auditor-General's 2023 non-compliance report says the Nigeria Police Force bought 41 vehicles for N3,238,387,012.50 that year, had insured none of them when auditors called in July 2024, and had not insured its aircraft in 2023. The force gave no response to that query or to the two others on it. Vero Record set the queries against the 2023 Appropriation Act, which gave the force's budget head N394,041,059 for insurance premium, N5.81 billion for aircraft maintenance and fuel and N2.63 billion for patrol vehicles. The 2026 Act raises the premium line to N573,471,697.

A blue armoured Nigeria Police truck marked POLICE and RRS parked at the roadside in Lagos, with two uniformed officers sitting on a bench beside it in front of a wall and a house
Photo · A Nigeria Police Rapid Response Squad truck at the roadside in Lagos, November 2009. The Auditor-General says the force bought 41 vehicles in 2023 and had insured none of them by July 2024. Photo: satanoid from Austin, TX, USA, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The Nigeria Police Force bought 41 vehicles for N3,238,387,012.50 in 2023 and, when the Auditor-General's team audited its Abuja headquarters in July 2024, had insured none of them. Its aircraft had not been insured in 2023 either. That year's Appropriation Act gave Police Formations and Commands, the head under which the Act funds the force, N394,041,059 for "Insurance premium". Asked to explain, the force gave the Auditor-General no response.

Auditor-General's report, Nigeria Police Force Headquarters, Abuja, period 1 January to 31 December 2023, Issue 1: non-insurance of newly acquired vehicles, N3,238,387,012.50; the force acquired 41 vehicles for that sum in 2023; they were not insured and no policies or certificates were obtained at the time of audit in July 2024; the force's aircraft were also not insured in 2023; management's response: No response; findings remain valid
Document · Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2023 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), Nigeria Police Force Headquarters, Abuja, pp.615-616

The query is the first of three on the force's headquarters in the Auditor-General for the Federation's 2023 Annual Report on Non-compliance, Volume II, on printed pages 615 to 617, covering 1 January to 31 December 2023. Under each of the three, the report prints the same words for the management's response: "No response." The auditors therefore record that the findings "remain valid" and ask that the Inspector-General of Police account to the Public Accounts Committees of the National Assembly. An audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing, and where the report says policies and certificates "were not obtained at the time of audit", it means the auditors were not shown them. Vero Record set the queries against the 2023 Appropriation Act file for the Federal Ministry of Police Affairs, as published by the Budget Office of the Federation, and against the 2026 Act.

The Act gives the Ministry of Police Affairs N838,058,470,985 for 2023 under three heads: the ministry itself, the Police Academy in Wudil and Police Formations and Commands. The last takes N827,923,448,003, or 98.8 per cent: N722,123,657,003 for personnel, N46,653,116,115 for overheads and N59,146,674,885 for capital, which re-add to the total. There is no head named Nigeria Police Force. Inside the overheads, the subhead for financial charges is N548,564,885: N41,023,821 for bank charges, N394,041,059 on line 22020902 for insurance premium and N113,500,005 for loss on foreign exchange.

2023 Appropriation Act, Federal Ministry of Police Affairs: summary showing Police Formations and Commands at N827,923,448,003 of N838,058,470,985; the head's schedule with financial charges N548,564,885, bank charges N41,023,821 and insurance premium N394,041,059, and totals of N46,653,116,115 overhead and N59,146,674,885 capital; below, the 2026 Act's schedule for the same head with insurance premium N573,471,697 and a total allocation of N1,302,980,676,404
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Police Affairs, pp.1, 6 and 7; National Assembly, 2026 Appropriation Act, pp.333-335

The premium vote is 12.2 per cent of what the auditors say the 41 vehicles cost. That does not show the force had money set aside for these vehicles in particular. The premium line covers everything insured under the head, and the report does not say what a policy on the 41 vehicles would have cost, what else the force insures, or how much of the N394,041,059 was released or spent. What the Act does show is that the National Assembly voted a premium line for the force's commands in the year the auditors examined.

The aircraft finding is a single sentence: "The Nigeria Police Force aircrafts were also not insured in the year 2023." The report does not say how many aircraft the force has. The 2023 Act gives the same head N1,784,092,678 for maintenance of aircraft and N4,029,009,032 for aircraft fuel, N5,813,101,710 between them, and a capital project, ERGP4103055, of N489,317,686 for aircraft spare parts, ground handling and hangar equipment and the "reactivation of Bell helicopters".

The auditors do not question the purchase of the vehicles, only the absence of cover, and on this point the record sits with the force as far as it goes: the Act voted money to buy vehicles. Its capital list carries project ERGP4173016, "Purchase of patrol/operational vehicles", at N2,626,719,024, the same figure the Act books under economic line 23010107, "Purchase of trucks". Smaller project lines also include vehicles, among them N150,000,000 for "security vehicles for outfits in Yuli & other locations in North Central Zone". The report names no models, supplier or budget line for the 41 vehicles. Their price averages N78,985,049.09 each, and the total is N611,667,988.50 more than the patrol vehicle line, so the report does not show which line, or which year's money, paid for them.

2023 Appropriation Act, Police Formations and Commands: maintenance of aircrafts N1,784,092,678; aircraft fuel cost N4,029,009,032; purchase of trucks N2,626,719,024; capital project ERGP4173016, purchase of patrol/operational vehicles, ongoing, N2,626,719,024
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Police Affairs, Police Formations and Commands, pp.6, 7 and 12

The rule the auditors cite is an Establishment Circular of 21 July 2008, reference SGF/OP/I/S.3/VII/981, which requires ministries, departments and agencies to keep all their assets "fully and adequately insured with registered insurance companies", and section 68 of the National Insurance Act of 1997, which bars any vehicle, government vehicles included, from the road unless third-party liability is insured with a registered insurer. They ask the Inspector-General to account for the N3,238,387,012.50 to the Public Accounts Committees and to "provide justification for the exposure of government assets to huge risk relating to non-insurance", failing which the sanctions for gross misconduct in paragraph 3129 of the Financial Regulations should apply.

The 2026 Appropriation Act raises the premium line for Police Formations and Commands to N573,471,697, N179,430,638 or 45.5 per cent more than in 2023, inside financial charges of N798,359,532. The head's 2026 total is N1,302,980,676,404: N1,183,242,631,967 for personnel, N71,183,449,597 for overheads and N48,554,594,840 for capital. Nothing in the records obtained shows whether the 41 vehicles or the aircraft have since been insured.

The second query is for N287,502,085.00. The auditors say the force paid contractors that sum through 21 overhead vouchers "for the settlement of previous year's liabilities", and that there was "no evidence that these expenditures were provided for, in year 2023 Approved Estimates". The Financial Regulations they quote require a supplementary provision or a virement when last year's commitments cannot be met from this year's estimates. Vero Record searched the whole 2023 Act file for the ministry: no line in it carries the words liabilities or arrears. The sum is 0.62 per cent of the head's N46,653,116,115 overhead vote. The report does not name the contractors or say which year the debts were from. It asks that the sum be recovered and remitted to the Treasury.

Auditor-General's report, Nigeria Police Force Headquarters, Issue 2: payment of prior year's liabilities from current year's allocation, N287,502,085.00; paid to contractors through 21 overhead vouchers to settle previous year's liabilities, with no evidence they were provided for in the 2023 approved estimates; management's response: No response
Document · Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2023 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), Nigeria Police Force Headquarters, Abuja, pp.616-617

The third query carries no figure. The auditors found "a significant number of obsolete firearms" in the armoury at Force Headquarters which, "though obsolete, were still lethal and could be misused", and no evidence that the force had begun the process of destroying them under the Financial Regulations. They ask the Inspector-General to account to the Public Accounts Committees for all obsolete firearms and ammunition held there and to send a full record of unserviceable weapons and of expended ammunition. The report does not say how many weapons are involved.

The force's three queries follow eleven on its supervising ministry, the Federal Ministry of Police Affairs, on pages 602 to 614 of the same volume. For the force itself there is no answer in the record at all. The report does not say whether the force was sent the queries in good time, or whether it has replied since the volume was published. Vero Record did not ask the force for comment.

What the two documents establish together is narrow and checkable: the auditors counted N3.24 billion of new police vehicles with no insurance in July 2024 and no insured aircraft in 2023, and the Act for the year they examined carried a premium vote of N394.04 million and N5.81 billion for aircraft maintenance and fuel. They do not establish that any money was misspent, and nothing here alleges a crime.

What this rests on

Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2023 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), section on Nigeria Police Force Headquarters, Abuja, printed pp.615-617 (PDF pp.262-264 of the copy downloaded from oaugf.ng), period 1 January to 31 December 2023: Issue 1 (non-insurance of newly acquired vehicles, N3,238,387,012.50; 41 vehicles; not insured at the time of audit in July 2024; aircraft not insured in 2023; management's response "No response") pp.615-616; Issue 2 (prior year's liabilities from current year's allocation, N287,502,085.00, 21 overhead vouchers, "No response") pp.616-617; Issue 3 (obsolete firearms, no figure, "No response") pp.617-618. The scanned pages were read by OCR and checked against page images; a 4-page extract (pp.615-618) is saved with this story. The ministry's own section (11 issues) was read from pp.602-614. 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Police Affairs (Budget Office of the Federation), downloaded 21 November 2026: summary by MDAs p.1; Police Formations and Commands schedule pp.6-7 (aircraft maintenance p.6; aircraft fuel, insurance premium, purchase of trucks and totals p.7); capital projects pp.7-13 (ERGP14192231 p.8; ERGP4103055 p.11; ERGP4173016 p.12). The running header on pp.6-8 reads "0155001001 Federal Ministry of Police Affairs", but the lines continue the schedule headed 0155004001 Police Formations and Commands on p.6 and close with its total of N827,923,448,003 on p.7. 2026 Appropriation Act (PLAC copy), Police Formations and Commands, pp.333-335 (same running-header quirk on p.334; the schedule closes with its own total of N1,302,980,676,404 on p.335). Arithmetic: 2023 head 722,123,657,003 + 46,653,116,115 + 59,146,674,885 = 827,923,448,003; 827,923,448,003 / 838,058,470,985 = 98.8%; financial charges 41,023,821 + 394,041,059 + 113,500,005 = 548,564,885; 394,041,059 / 3,238,387,012.50 = 12.17%; aircraft 1,784,092,678 + 4,029,009,032 = 5,813,101,710; 3,238,387,012.50 / 41 = 78,985,049.09; 3,238,387,012.50 - 2,626,719,024 = 611,667,988.50; 2026 head 1,183,242,631,967 + 71,183,449,597 + 48,554,594,840 = 1,302,980,676,404; 2026 financial charges 59,704,439 + 573,471,697 + 165,183,396 = 798,359,532; 573,471,697 - 394,041,059 = 179,430,638, and 573,471,697 / 394,041,059 = 1.455; 287,502,085 / 46,653,116,115 = 0.62%. Text search of the 2023 ministry file for "liabilit" and "arrear": no match.

What this does not establish

What models the 41 vehicles are, who supplied them, which budget line and which year's money paid for them, and whether any of them, or any police aircraft, has been insured since July 2024. How many aircraft the force operates. How much of the 2023 insurance premium vote of N394,041,059 was released and spent, and on what policies; whether insuring 41 vehicles and the aircraft would have fit within it. Who the contractors paid N287,502,085 were and which year their claims arose in. How many obsolete firearms are in the armoury. Whether the force was given the queries in time to answer, and whether it has answered the Public Accounts Committees since. Whether the committees have heard the force on this report. Nothing here alleges a crime; an audit query is not a finding of wrongdoing. The force was not asked for comment.

What we did ourselves

Read the three queries on the force's headquarters from the scanned audit volume, rendering only those pages, and read the eleven queries on the supervising ministry for context. Downloaded the 2023 Appropriation Act file for the Federal Ministry of Police Affairs and found the head that funds the force, its insurance premium line, its aircraft maintenance and fuel lines and its vehicle purchase lines. Re-added the head's 2023 and 2026 totals and financial charges, compared the premium vote with the price of the 41 vehicles, set the vehicles' price against the patrol vehicle line, searched the Act file for any line for liabilities or arrears, and read the 2026 premium line.

Sources for this report

(A) Office of the Auditor-General for the Federation, 2023 Annual Report on Non-compliance (Vol. II), Nigeria Police Force Headquarters, Abuja, pp.615-617; 2023 Appropriation Act by sector, Federal Ministry of Police Affairs, Police Formations and Commands, pp.1, 6, 7, 8, 11 and 12; 2026 Appropriation Act, Police Formations and Commands, pp.333-335.

Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.

Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.

Corrections

None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.

Investigations editor, Vero Record

Reads the Nigerian public record that others leave unread: budgets, audit reports, court files and registers. Every claim on this page carries the grade of the document behind it, and the report says what that document does not establish.

More on this record