Every claim graded  ·  No advertising  ·  Corrections published in place
Vero Record

Reporting and documentary investigation from Nigeria. What the paper says, and what it does not.

Politics  / 

ADC says no year since 2023 reached 70% project implementation. Budget Office tables agree for ministries, at 61.15% and 51.85%, not for all capital

The ADC campaign's media director, Kola Ologbondiyan, said on 1 November that the Tinubu government has not achieved 70 per cent project implementation since 2023. The Budget Office of the Federation's own reports back him on the line that pays for ministries' projects: 61.15 per cent of the 2023 budget for it was spent within the year, 51.85 per cent in 2024, N17.71 billion of N5.72 trillion in the first nine months of 2025 and nothing of the 2026 line by 30 June. They do not back him on total capital spending, which the same tables put at 79.99 per cent in 2023 and 84.14 per cent in 2024, the second figure counting N2.23 trillion spent in 2025.

People walk across the steel reinforcement mesh of a concrete road under construction at Bogije in Lagos State, with a yellow paving machine and a tipper truck behind them
Photo · Concrete road under construction at Bogije, Lagos State, February 2023. Photo: Ayodele Adeniji, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

On 1 November 2026 Tribune Online published an interview with Kola Ologbondiyan, Director of Media and Publicity of the African Democratic Congress Presidential Campaign Council, in which he said of President Bola Tinubu's government: "They haven't achieved 70 per cent project implementation since 2023 till today." Vero Record set the claim against the Budget Office of the Federation's implementation reports for 2023, 2024, 2025 and the first half of 2026. On the budget line that pays for ministries' own projects, the record backs him in every year. Ministries, departments and agencies spent 61.15 per cent of their 2023 capital budget within the year and 51.85 per cent of their 2024 capital budget, N17.71 billion of a N5.72 trillion line in the first nine months of 2025, and nothing of their 2026 line by 30 June 2026. On the Budget Office's broadest measure, total capital expenditure, 2023 reached 79.99 per cent and 2024 reached 84.14 per cent, though the 2024 figure includes N2.23 trillion spent in 2025.

Mr Ologbondiyan, who the newspaper says is also Special Adviser on Media and Publicity to the ADC's National Chairman, David Mark, made the remark while answering a question about the projects the federal government lists as built with loans, including the Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway and the Sokoto-Badagry Superhighway. He did not define "project implementation" or name a source for the figure. Read as money, it can mean two things the Budget Office measures: the share of the capital budget actually spent, or the share of the money released to ministries that they went on to use. This report tests both. Neither measures whether a road or building was finished.

The Budget Office's quarterly and year-end reports, produced under the Fiscal Responsibility Act, carry two relevant tables. Table 3.9, the fiscal account compiled with the Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, sets each capital line's budget against the amount spent in each quarter. Table 3.10 sets the main ministries' capital appropriation against the money released, cash-backed and utilised. The figures below come from those tables in the fourth-quarter reports for 2023 and 2024, the third-quarter report for 2025 and the second-quarter report for 2026.

For 2023, a year in which Mr Tinubu took office on 29 May under a budget passed by his predecessor, Table 3.9 on page 34 of the fourth-quarter report gives capital expenditure by MDAs and others of N3,246.27 billion against a budget of N5,308.45 billion, or 61.15 per cent. Total capital expenditure, which adds government-owned enterprises, project-tied loans and grants, was N6,365.86 billion against N7,958.27 billion, or 79.99 per cent. That total is lifted by one line: grants and donor-funded projects came to N1,572.50 billion against a budget of N43.03 billion. Table 3.10 on page 36, dated 31 December 2023, shows MDAs used N2,963.99 billion, which is 45.02 per cent of their appropriation of N6,583.41 billion and 81.13 per cent of the N3,653.20 billion released to them.

2024 was the first full year of the present government's own budget. Table 3.9 on page 33 of the fourth-quarter report, marked provisional, gives capital expenditure by MDAs and others of N5,814.41 billion against a budget of N11,214.82 billion, or 51.85 per cent. A separate line headed "Capital Dev. Fund (Main)-2024 in 2025" adds N2,231.45 billion spent in 2025, after the 2024 capital budget's implementation period was extended to December 2025, as a note on the report's cover says. Counting that money, the ministries' line reaches 71.74 per cent, the only figure for ministries in these reports above 70, and only once the following year's spending is included. Total capital expenditure was N11,589.17 billion against N13,773.28 billion, or 84.14 per cent; without the N2,231.45 billion spent in 2025 it is N9,357.72 billion, or 67.94 per cent. Project-tied loans contributed N1,981.36 billion against N1,051.91 billion budgeted.

Budget Office Table 3.9, capital rows for 2024: capital expenditure by MDAs and others N5,814.41bn against a budget of N11,214.82bn; Capital Dev. Fund (Main)-2024 in 2025 N2,231.45bn; total capital expenditure N11,589.17bn against N13,773.28bn; 2023 actuals N3,246.27bn and N6,365.86bn
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2024 Fourth Quarter and Consolidated Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.9, p.33

The same 2024 report gives other measures. Its Table 3.10 on page 35, dated 30 June 2025, shows MDAs with an appropriation of N8,493,664,163,085, releases of N3,998,590,332,378 and utilisation of N3,275,313,763,463: 38.56 per cent of the appropriation and 81.91 per cent of what was released. Its text on page 34 says N13.77 trillion was appropriated for capital and N6.17 trillion spent, which is 44.79 per cent and equals the MDA and government-owned enterprise lines of Table 3.9 added together. The minister's foreword says N5.81 trillion was released with an 81.91 per cent utilisation rate, while the body of the report puts releases at N4.00 trillion and gives N5.81 trillion as the amount spent. Depending on which line is read, the report's 2024 capital performance runs from 38.56 to 84.14 per cent.

Budget Office Table 3.10, capital budget utilisation by MDAs as at 30 June 2025, total row: appropriation N8,493,664,163,085, released N3,998,590,332,378, utilised N3,275,313,763,463, 38.56 per cent of appropriation and 81.91 per cent of releases
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2024 Fourth Quarter and Consolidated Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.10, p.35

For 2025 the Budget Office's website listed reports for the first three quarters only when Vero Record checked on 20 November 2026. Table 3.9 on page 28 of the third-quarter report records capital expenditure by MDAs of N1.63 billion in the first quarter, nothing in the second and N16.08 billion in the third, a total of N17.71 billion against an annual budget of N5,717.40 billion, or 0.31 per cent. Total capital expenditure was N6,600.01 billion against N16,765.33 billion, or 39.37 per cent of the year's budget and 52.49 per cent of the nine-month share, and N4,786.46 billion of it came through project-tied loans. These are not final figures: the 2025 capital budget's implementation was extended to 31 December 2026, and the second-quarter report for 2026 records a further N677.14 billion of "Capital Expenditure (MDAs) 2025 in 2026" in April to June 2026.

Budget Office Table 3.9, capital rows to September 2025: capital expenditure by MDAs N1.63bn, N0.00 and N16.08bn in the three quarters, N17.71bn in total against a budget of N5,717.40bn; total capital expenditure N6,600.01bn against N16,765.33bn
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2025 Third Quarter Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.9, p.28

For 2026, Table 3.9 on page 36 of the second-quarter report gives the MDAs' capital budget as N15,681.76 billion, 48.57 per cent of a total capital budget of N32,287.06 billion, and records 0.00 against it in both quarters. The report says on page 37 that "Implementation of the MDAs' 2026 capital budget was zero as at 30 June 2026, reflecting the extension of the utilisation period for funds released under the 2025 capital budget to 31st December 2026." Total capital expenditure in the half-year was N4,177.34 billion, 12.94 per cent of the annual capital budget and 25.88 per cent of the half-year share.

Budget Office Table 3.9, capital rows to June 2026: capital expenditure by MDAs 0.00 in both quarters against a budget of N15,681.76bn; capital expenditure (MDAs) 2025 in 2026 N677.14bn; total capital expenditure N4,177.34bn against N32,287.06bn
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, Second Quarter and Half-Year 2026 Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.9, p.36

The record supports the ADC on the measure closest to the projects ministries run. In no year from 2023 to the middle of 2026 did MDAs spend 70 per cent of their capital budget within that year, and the 2025 and 2026 figures for that line were close to or at zero at the latest reported dates. The record supports the government on two points. Measured against what was released, MDAs used 81.13 per cent in 2023 and 81.91 per cent in 2024, so the larger gap is between what was budgeted and what was released. And on the Budget Office's widest line, total capital expenditure including project-tied loans and grants, 2023 and 2024 both passed 70 per cent, though 2024 does so only with spending carried into 2025.

The reports also show why in-year figures understate eventual spending. Since 2024 each year's capital budget has been extended into the following year, so in 2025 and 2026 money from the previous budget was being spent while the new year's ministries' line showed little or nothing. Final figures for the 2024 budget after its extension ended in December 2025, and for the 2025 budget, have not been published in these reports. None of the documents measures physical completion of projects.

Set against the Budget Office's own tables, Mr Ologbondiyan's figure holds for the ministries' capital line in every year he named and fails for total capital expenditure in 2023 and 2024. Nothing in these records suggests wrongdoing by anyone.

What this rests on

Documents read: Budget Office of the Federation, Fourth Quarter and Consolidated 2023 Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.9 p.34 (PDF p.49) and Table 3.10 p.36 (PDF p.51); 2024 Fourth Quarter and Consolidated Budget Implementation Report [Provisional], cover note (PDF p.1), foreword p.i (PDF p.2), text p.34 (PDF p.48), Table 3.9 p.33 (PDF p.47), Table 3.10 p.35 (PDF p.49); 2025 Third Quarter Budget Implementation Report (posted as the reviewed third-quarter analysis), Table 3.9 p.28 (PDF p.47); Second Quarter and Half-Year 2026 Budget Implementation Report, summary p.xv (PDF p.16), Table 3.9 p.36 (PDF p.52), section 3.10.7 p.37 (PDF p.53); Tribune Online interview, 1 November 2026. Arithmetic re-done (naira billion unless stated). 2023: MDAs Q1 to Q4 215.21 + 800.09 + 760.89 + 1,470.08 = 3,246.27; 3,246.27 / 5,308.45 = 61.15%. Total capital actual 3,246.27 + 573.13 (GOEs) + 973.96 (project-tied loans) + 1,572.50 (grants) = 6,365.86; budget 5,308.45 + 835.39 + 1,771.40 + 43.03 = 7,958.27; 6,365.86 / 7,958.27 = 79.99%. (The printed quarterly figures on the 2023 total row do not add to 6,365.86; the component rows do.) Table 3.10: 2,963,992,095,177 / 6,583,405,428,174 = 45.02%; / 3,653,198,483,299 = 81.13%. 2024: MDAs 450.13 + 1,849.55 + 1,953.43 + 1,561.30 = 5,814.41; 5,814.41 / 11,214.82 = 51.85%; with 2,231.45 spent in 2025: 8,045.86 / 11,214.82 = 71.74%. Total capital quarters 824.36 + 2,075.20 + 2,248.88 + 6,440.73 = 11,589.17; components 5,814.41 + 2,231.45 + 354.99 + 1,981.36 + 1,206.95 = 11,589.16 (rounding); fourth quarter 1,561.30 + 2,231.45 + 247.77 + 1,981.36 + 418.84 = 6,440.72 (rounding); budget 11,214.82 + 820.91 + 1,051.91 + 685.63 = 13,773.27 (printed 13,773.28); 11,589.17 / 13,773.28 = 84.14%; 11,589.17 - 2,231.45 = 9,357.72; / 13,773.28 = 67.94%. Loans 1,981.36 / 1,051.91 = 188.36%. Text figure 5,814.41 + 354.99 = 6,169.40 (printed N6.17tn); 6.17 / 13.77 = 44.79%. Table 3.10: 3,275,313,763,463 / 8,493,664,163,085 = 38.56%; / 3,998,590,332,378 = 81.91%. 2025 (nine months): MDAs 1.63 + 0.00 + 16.08 = 17.71; 17.71 / 5,717.40 = 0.31%; total capital 17.71 + 615.68 + 100.10 + 0.00 + 4,786.46 + 1,080.06 = 6,600.01; 6,600.01 / 16,765.33 = 39.37%; / 12,574.00 = 52.49%. 2026 (half-year): MDAs 0.00 of 15,681.76; 15,681.76 / 32,287.06 = 48.57%; total capital 0.00 + 677.14 + 494.38 + 62.34 + 949.25 + 515.33 + 1,024.46 + 454.44 = 4,177.34; 4,177.34 / 32,287.06 = 12.94%; / 16,143.53 = 25.88%.

What this does not establish

What Mr Ologbondiyan meant by "project implementation" and what source, if any, he used; the interview gives none. Whether federal projects were physically completed; the Budget Office reports measure money, not completion. Final capital spending for the 2024 budget after its extension ended in December 2025, and for the 2025 budget, which runs to 31 December 2026; no fourth-quarter 2025 report was listed on the Budget Office's website on 20 November 2026. Why the 2024 report's foreword gives N5.81 trillion as released when its body gives N4.00 trillion released and N5.81 trillion spent, and why its Table 3.10 appropriation (N8.49 trillion) differs from the N11.21 trillion MDA line in Table 3.9; the report does not reconcile them. The 2023 report's list of tables dates Table 3.10 to "31st June, 2024" while the table itself says 31 December 2023. The 2024 figures are marked provisional. The 2023 capital budget was passed before Mr Tinubu took office. Vero Record did not put these figures to the ADC or to the Budget Office before publication. Nothing in this report suggests wrongdoing by anyone.

What we did ourselves

Took the claim from Tribune Online's interview of 1 November 2026, saved from the newspaper's site. Read the capital expenditure lines of Table 3.9 and the MDA utilisation totals of Table 3.10 in four Budget Office implementation reports covering 2023 to June 2026, re-added every quarterly series and every total against its components, and computed each year's spending as a share of the annual budget and of releases. Checked the Budget Office's listing pages for 2025 and 2026 reports on 20 November 2026. Compared the 2024 report's foreword, text and two tables against each other.

Sources for this report

(A) Budget Office of the Federation, 2023 Fourth Quarter Budget Implementation Report, pp.34 and 36; 2024 Fourth Quarter and Consolidated Budget Implementation Report [Provisional], cover, p.i, pp.33 to 35; 2025 Third Quarter Budget Implementation Report, p.28; Second Quarter and Half-Year 2026 Budget Implementation Report, pp.xv, 36 and 37.

Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.

Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.

Corrections

None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.

Investigations editor, Vero Record

Reads the Nigerian public record that others leave unread: budgets, audit reports, court files and registers. Every claim on this page carries the grade of the document behind it, and the report says what that document does not establish.

More on this record