Every claim graded  ·  No advertising  ·  Corrections published in place
Vero Record

Reporting and documentary investigation from Nigeria. What the paper says, and what it does not.

Politics  / 

Alake put solid minerals revenue at N6bn in 2023 and N38bn in 2024; the Budget Office's tables say N14.94bn and N26.98bn, and NEITI agrees on 2023

At the APC's manifesto launch on 10 November, the Minister of Solid Minerals Development, Dele Alake, said his sector's revenue rose from N6bn in 2023 to N38bn in 2024, N70bn in 2025 and more than N101bn in the first nine months of 2026. The Budget Office's implementation reports put 2023 at N14.94bn and 2024 at N26.98bn, and NEITI's 2023 audit counts N14.89bn paid into the solid minerals revenue account that year. The same records support a steep rise since: N51.79bn in the first nine months of 2025, a N68.10bn sharing of mining revenue in April 2026, and N55.11bn in the first half of 2026 alone. The N101bn cannot yet be checked.

A hand-dug mining pit in reddish earth at a tin mining site in Vom, Plateau State
Photo · A mining pit at a tin mining site in Vom, Plateau State, January 2023. Photo: Gwazachat, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Dele Alake, the Minister of Solid Minerals Development, told the launch of the All Progressives Congress's 2027 to 2031 manifesto in Abuja on Tuesday, 10 November 2026, that revenue from his sector had risen from N6bn in 2023 to N38bn in 2024 and N70bn in 2025, and that Central Bank figures put it above N101bn for January to September 2026. Vero Record set those figures against three sets of government records: the Budget Office of the Federation's budget implementation reports, the Nigeria Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative's (NEITI) audit of the sector for 2023, and the monthly Federation Account tables of the Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation. The rise he described is in the record. His starting point is not. The Budget Office's tables put solid minerals revenue at N14.94bn in 2023 and N26.98bn in 2024, and NEITI's audit counts N14,889,414,335.43 paid into the solid minerals revenue account in 2023.

BusinessDay reported the remarks the same day. It quotes Mr Alake as saying that in 2023 "the total revenue that the sector generated was N6bn", that "within one year, in 2024, it rose to N38bn" and that "By 2025, it rose to N70bn". The N101bn figure and its attribution to Central Bank figures are given in the newspaper's own words. Mr Alake also speaks for the APC Presidential Campaign Council. Vero Record did not hear a recording of the speech. He has used the N6bn starting point before: a State House statement reported by Arise News on 25 May 2025 quoted him as saying the sector generated about N6bn a year when the administration took office. His office has also used other numbers. In January 2026 his media aide, Segun Tomori, gave the 2023 figure as N16bn, according to Vanguard, and a paper the minister presented in Abuja, reported by Arise News on 1 May 2026, put revenue for 2025 at about N68.1bn.

The Budget Office's quarterly implementation reports, compiled with the Accountant-General's office, carry a line called "Total Solid Minerals Revenue" in their table of distributable revenue, Table 3.4. In the fourth-quarter report for 2024, that line shows N3.41bn, N5.32bn, N7.30bn and N10.95bn for the four quarters of 2024, which add to the N26.98bn printed for the year, and N14.94bn in the column for 2023. The 2023 fourth-quarter report gives the same N14.94bn, built from quarters of N2.29bn, N3.28bn, N4.99bn and N4.37bn (these add to N14.93bn; the difference is rounding), and N11.29bn for 2022. The 2024 table puts the rise from 2023 to 2024 at N12.04bn, or 80.57 per cent. That is a large increase. It is not an increase from N6bn to N38bn.

Budget Office Table 3.4, net distributable revenue as at December 2024, line 20 Total Solid Minerals Revenue: 2024 budget N10.85bn; actual N3.41bn, N5.32bn, N7.30bn and N10.95bn by quarter, N26.98bn for the year; 2023 actual N14.94bn; 2024 against 2023 up N12.04bn, 80.57%
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2024 Fourth Quarter Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.4, p.23

NEITI's 2023 Solid Minerals Industry Audit Report, prepared by the independent administrator Haruna Yahaya and Co. and published in 2024, reaches the same order of magnitude by a different route. Its Table 62, which it sources to the Federation Account Allocation Committee's report for 2023, lists the money paid into the solid minerals revenue account month by month, from N806,098,677.37 in January to N2,005,102,063.51 in December. The twelve months add to N14,889,414,335.43, and the text above the table says: "The total revenue accrued to the solid minerals revenue account in 2023 was N14.88billion." The audit's figures for the ministry's two collecting agencies agree. The Mines Inspectorate Department, which collects royalties, received N9,061,710,799 in 2023, N9,012,650,637 of it royalty, and the Mining Cadastre Office, which collects fees for mining titles, received N6,071,263,462. Together that is N15,132,974,261. NEITI's five-year table on page 144 gives the Cadastre Office N7,483 million for 2023 instead, which would make N16,545 million for the two agencies, close to the N16bn the minister's office gave in January.

NEITI Table 62, 2023 Solid Minerals Revenue Account: opening balance N16,680,990,990.93 distributed in May; monthly inflows from N806,098,677.37 in January to N2,005,102,063.51 in December; closing balance N14,889,414,335.43; text says revenue accrued in 2023 was N14.88billion
Document · NEITI, Solid Minerals Industry Audit Report 2023, section 5.2 and Table 62, p.156

No figure of N6bn for the sector's revenue in 2023 appears in either record. The nearest numbers in NEITI's tables are parts of the whole: the Cadastre Office's N6,071,263,462 on its own in 2023, and the Mines Inspectorate's N6,311,745,729 in 2022. On NEITI's widest measure, which adds the taxes that mining and quarrying companies paid to the Federal Inland Revenue Service and to state revenue services, the sector paid N401,868,627,340 to government in 2023, of which N370,088,887,359 went to the federal tax service. The minister's later figures, N38bn and N70bn, are of the size of the narrower stream of royalties and fees, and on that stream both records put 2023 at about N14.9bn.

The starting point changes the size of the claim. Measured from N6bn, N70bn would be 11.7 times the 2023 level and N101bn 16.8 times. Measured from the Budget Office's N14.94bn, the same N70bn would be 4.7 times and N101bn 6.8 times. Either way the increase is large, but the N6bn base makes the multiple about two and a half times as large as the government's own tables support.

For 2024, the minister's N38bn is N11.02bn, or 40.85 per cent, above the Budget Office's N26.98bn. The Accountant-General's monthly tables, which record what the Federation Account Allocation Committee shares out, do not close that gap. In the 32 monthly tables from January 2024 to August 2026, solid minerals money was shared three times: N13,647,077,128.84 in August 2024, N28,218,818,355.40 in March 2025 and N68,096,347,073.22 in April 2026. The account is shared in lump sums rather than every month. NEITI's Table 62 shows that the N16,680,990,990.93 shared in May 2023 was the balance the account had carried into that year, and the Accountant-General's table for May 2023 shows the same sum.

For 2025 the record is closer to the minister. The Budget Office's third-quarter report shows N10.10bn, N22.29bn and N19.40bn for the first three quarters, N51.79bn in all, against a budget of N36.88bn for the whole year. The fourth-quarter report for 2025 has not been published, but a fourth quarter of N18.21bn, smaller than either of the two before it, would bring the year to N70bn. In April 2026 the Accountant-General's Table I shared N68,096,347,073.22 under "Distribution from Solid Minerals Revenue": N31,209,645,405.21 to the Federal Government, N15,829,949,226.03 to the states, N12,204,227,322.46 to local councils and N8,852,525,119.52, which is 13 per cent, to the derivation fund. That is the largest of the four solid minerals distributions in the tables since May 2023, and rounded to one decimal place it equals the N68.1bn the minister gave for 2025 in the paper reported on 1 May. The tables do not say over which months the money was collected.

Accountant-General's Table I for March 2026 revenue shared in April 2026: Distribution from Solid Minerals Revenue N31,209,645,405.21 to the FGN, N15,829,949,226.03 to states, N12,204,227,322.46 to LGCs, N8,852,525,119.52 to the 13% derivation fund; total N68,096,347,073.22
Document · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, FAAC Table I, April 2026, p.1

The 2026 figures so far are strong. The Budget Office's second-quarter report for 2026 records N15.62bn of solid minerals revenue in the first quarter and N39.48bn in the second, the highest quarter in any of the reports read for this article, for N55.11bn in the half year. The report puts that N7.13bn, or 14.87 per cent, above the half-year budget of N47.97bn, and notes that solid minerals was one of only two non-oil revenue lines to beat its estimate in the second quarter. The half-year total is 70.1 per cent more than the N32.39bn of the first half of 2025. Whether the nine-month total passed N101bn cannot yet be checked. It would need a third quarter of at least N45.89bn, above any quarter so far, and the Budget Office has not published its third-quarter report for 2026. A total above N101bn would also exceed the N95.95bn the 2026 budget expects from solid minerals for the whole year.

Budget Office Table 3.4, distributable revenue as at June 2026, line 20 Total Solid Minerals Revenue: 2026 budget N95.95bn, half-year budget N47.97bn; actual N15.62bn first quarter, N39.48bn second quarter, N55.11bn half year; N7.13bn, 14.87%, above the half-year budget
Document · Budget Office of the Federation, 2026 Second Quarter Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.4, p.24

The Budget Office line and NEITI's account appear to measure the same stream: royalties, title fees and similar payments collected by the ministry's agencies and paid into the Federation Account, before 13 per cent is set aside for derivation. NEITI's report says the Cadastre Office's and the Inspectorate's 2023 receipts were transferred into the Federation Account, and its N14,889,414,335.43 for the account in 2023 is about N0.05bn below the Budget Office's N14.94bn. BusinessDay's report does not say what the minister's own figures count, or which Central Bank publication he took the 2026 number from. Vero Record did not find a Central Bank series of solid minerals revenue to check it against.

Set side by side, the government's own papers support the minister on the direction and the pace of the recent increase. Solid minerals revenue rose by 80.57 per cent from 2023 to 2024, more than tripled between the first nine months of 2024 (N16.03bn) and the first nine months of 2025 (N51.79bn), and in the first half of 2026 alone came to more than the first nine months of 2025. The records are consistent with his N70bn for 2025. They do not support N6bn for 2023, which the Budget Office puts at N14.94bn and NEITI at N14.89bn, or N38bn for 2024, which the Budget Office puts at N26.98bn.

The records leave some questions open. NEITI has not yet published its audit for 2024, so the Budget Office's figure for that year has no second audited source. The Accountant-General's tables show when money was shared, not when it was collected. The ministry was not asked for comment before publication; the figures above are the government's own, set against the minister's. Nothing in the documents suggests wrongdoing by anyone.

What this rests on

Budget Office of the Federation budget implementation reports, Table 3.4 (distributable revenue, source OAGF and Budget Office), line 20 "Total Solid Minerals Revenue": Fourth Quarter and Consolidated 2023 report (printed p.24, PDF p.39); 2024 Fourth Quarter report (printed p.23, PDF p.37); 2025 Third Quarter report (printed p.18, PDF p.37); 2026 Second Quarter report (printed p.24, PDF p.40, and narrative at PDF pp.38 to 39). NEITI Solid Minerals Industry Audit Report 2023 (Haruna Yahaya and Co., 2024; PDF created 18 December 2024): Table 1 (p.17), Tables 48 and 49 (pp.129 to 130), Table 59 (p.144), Tables 62 and 63 (pp.156 to 157). Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, FAAC disbursement Table I for May 2023, August 2024, March 2025 and April 2026, and page 1 of every monthly table from January 2024 to August 2026 (32 months). All retrieved and read for this report. Arithmetic re-done: 2023 quarters N2.29bn + N3.28bn + N4.99bn + N4.37bn = N14.93bn against N14.94bn printed (rounding); 2024 quarters N3.41bn + N5.32bn + N7.30bn + N10.95bn = N26.98bn; N26.98bn - N14.94bn = N12.04bn, 80.57 per cent as printed (80.59 per cent from the rounded figures); NEITI Table 62 monthly inflows N806,098,677.37 + N762,584,446.79 + N724,704,208.72 + N707,072,699.39 + N1,566,963,527.53 + N1,009,717,825.97 + N3,589,868,383.54 + N704,930,354.83 + N693,540,869.97 + N998,850,129.77 + N1,319,981,148.04 + N2,005,102,063.51 = N14,889,414,335.43, and opening N16,680,990,990.93 + inflows - May distribution N16,680,990,990.93 = closing N14,889,414,335.43; MID N9,061,710,799 + MCO N6,071,263,462 = N15,132,974,261; Table 59 MID N9,062m + MCO N7,483m = N16,545m; NEITI Table 1 parts add to N401,868,627,341 against N401,868,627,340 printed (N1 rounding); N14.94bn - N14,889,414,335.43 = about N0.05bn; N38bn - N26.98bn = N11.02bn, 40.85 per cent; N70bn / N6bn = 11.7, N101bn / N6bn = 16.8, N70bn / N14.94bn = 4.7, N101bn / N14.94bn = 6.8, 11.7 / 4.7 = about 2.5; 2025 quarters N10.10bn + N22.29bn + N19.40bn = N51.79bn, and N70bn - N51.79bn = N18.21bn; first nine months of 2024 N3.41bn + N5.32bn + N7.30bn = N16.03bn, and N51.79bn / N16.03bn = 3.23; 2026 quarters N15.62bn + N39.48bn = N55.10bn against N55.11bn printed (rounding); N55.11bn - N47.97bn = N7.14bn against N7.13bn printed; first half of 2025 N10.10bn + N22.29bn = N32.39bn, and N55.11bn / N32.39bn = 1.701; N101bn - N55.11bn = N45.89bn; N101bn - N95.95bn = N5.05bn; FAAC August 2024 N6,254,673,801.38 + N3,172,454,137.68 + N2,445,829,163.03 + N1,774,120,026.75 = N13,647,077,128.84; March 2025 N12,933,135,953.37 + N6,559,859,390.17 + N5,057,376,625.65 + N3,668,446,386.20 = N28,218,818,355.39 against N28,218,818,355.40 printed (1 kobo); April 2026 N31,209,645,405.21 + N15,829,949,226.03 + N12,204,227,322.46 + N8,852,525,119.52 = N68,096,347,073.22, derivation share 13.00 per cent; May 2023 N7,645,165,067.00 + N3,877,729,889.72 + N2,989,567,205.39 + N2,168,528,828.82 = N16,680,990,990.93; N70bn - N68,096,347,073.22 = about N1.90bn.

What this does not establish

What the minister's N6bn, N38bn and N70bn count, and which Central Bank figures he relied on for N101bn; no Central Bank series of solid minerals revenue was found. Revenue for the third quarter of 2026 and the fourth quarter of 2025, for which the Budget Office has not yet published reports. Which months of collections the Accountant-General's lump-sum distributions of August 2024, March 2025 and April 2026 cover. Why NEITI's report gives the Mining Cadastre Office N6,071,263,462 in one table and N7,483 million in another for 2023. A second audited figure for 2024, since NEITI's 2024 solid minerals audit has not been published. Vero Record did not hear a recording of the 10 November speech and relies on BusinessDay's account; the May 2025, January 2026 and May 2026 statements by the minister and his office are taken from press reports. The ministry was not asked for comment. Nothing in this report suggests wrongdoing by anyone.

What we did ourselves

Took the minister's figures from BusinessDay's report of the 10 November manifesto launch. Read the solid minerals line in four Budget Office implementation reports and re-added each year from its quarters. Downloaded NEITI's 2023 solid minerals audit from neiti.gov.ng, re-added the twelve monthly inflows to the solid minerals revenue account and the two collecting agencies' receipts, and compared them with the Budget Office's 2023 figure. Checked page 1 of all 32 Accountant-General FAAC tables from January 2024 to August 2026 for solid minerals distributions, re-added the four distributions found since 2023 against their totals, and matched the May 2023 distribution to NEITI's opening balance. Computed the growth multiples on the minister's base and on the Budget Office's, and the third-quarter 2026 figure his N101bn would require.

Sources for this report

(A) Budget Office of the Federation, Table 3.4 (Total Solid Minerals Revenue) in the 2023 and 2024 fourth-quarter, 2025 third-quarter and 2026 second-quarter budget implementation reports; NEITI Solid Minerals Industry Audit Report 2023, Tables 1, 48, 49, 59, 62 and 63; Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, FAAC Table I for May 2023, August 2024, March 2025 and April 2026.

Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.

Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.

Corrections

None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.

Investigations editor, Vero Record

Reads the Nigerian public record that others leave unread: budgets, audit reports, court files and registers. Every claim on this page carries the grade of the document behind it, and the report says what that document does not establish.

More on this record