Every claim graded  ·  No advertising  ·  Corrections published in place
Vero Record

Reporting and documentary investigation from Nigeria. What the paper says, and what it does not.

Politics  / 

Radda's N62bn-to-N14bn Katsina debt figures match DMO tables. His Auditor-General says N45.18bn of the fall was federal loans the FG liquidated

Katsina's governor, Dikko Umaru Radda, said on 8 October that the state's domestic debt fell from N62 billion in 2022 to N14 billion in 2025. The Debt Management Office's tables carry both numbers: N62.37 billion, a figure Katsina reported for September 2022, and N14.11 billion at the end of 2025. Measured from the DMO's last figure before he took office, N99.31 billion at March 2023, the fall is larger than he said. The state Auditor-General's 2025 report shows how most of the last year's drop happened: four federal loans worth N45.18 billion that it says "have been liquidated by the Federal Government of Nigeria", beside N10.75 billion of Sukuk bonds the state paid down.

The long red, green and yellow facade of the Emir of Katsina's palace, with a clock tower above an arched gateway, seen from street level under a blue sky with white clouds
Photo · The Emir's palace in Katsina, February 2022. Photo: SMMIMAGES, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

On 8 October 2026 Katsina State's governor, Dikko Umaru Radda, told a World Bank audience in Abuja that the state's domestic debt "has dropped from N62 billion in 2022 to N14 billion in 2025", a reduction of N48 billion. Vero Record set the claim against the Debt Management Office's state debt tables and against Katsina's own 2025 accounts and its Auditor-General's report on them. Both of his figures are in the DMO's tables: N62,374,809,154.32, which the DMO notes is Katsina's figure as at 30 September 2022, and N14,109,376,761.49 at 31 December 2025. The state's own records reach almost the same end point, N14,464,176,560.05. They also show that N45,178,660,129.68 of the N60.78 billion fall in 2025 was four federal loans that the Auditor-General says "have been liquidated by the Federal Government of Nigeria".

Mr Radda, elected for the All Progressives Congress, took office on 29 May 2023. ThisDay reported his remarks on 9 October, saying he spoke on the Thursday as a panellist at the launch of the World Bank's Nigeria Development Update at the Sheraton Hotel, and quoting a statement from his Chief Press Secretary, Ibrahim Kaula Mohammed. The governor was quoted as saying: "Our commitment to prudent financial management is reflected in the significant reduction of Katsina State's domestic debt, from N62 billion in 2022 to N14 billion in 2025. This represents a reduction of N48 billion and demonstrates our deliberate effort to strengthen the state's fiscal position." He also said internally generated revenue had risen "from about N600 million monthly in 2023 to over N3 billion monthly in 2026", and credited larger allocations from the Federation Account after President Bola Tinubu's reforms. The starting year he chose, 2022, was the last full year of his predecessor, Aminu Bello Masari.

The N62 billion is the DMO's number. Its table of domestic debt for the 36 states and the FCT as at 31 December 2022, built from "signed-off submissions" by the states, lists Katsina at N62,374,809,154.32, and a footnote says Katsina's figure was "as at September 30, 2022". The same N62,374,809,154.32 is printed in the DMO's tables for 31 March and 30 June 2023, each with a note that Katsina's figure still dated from September 2022.

Excerpts from the DMO's table of state domestic debt as at 31 December 2022: title, row 20 Katsina N62,374,809,154.32, and note 3 saying the figures for Katsina and Taraba were as at September 30, 2022
Document · Debt Management Office, Domestic Debt Data for the 36 States and the FCT as at December 31, 2022, p.1

The next Katsina figure the DMO published was higher. Its tables for 30 September and 31 December 2023 list Katsina at N99,313,694,044.20 and note that the figure is as at 31 March 2023, two months before Mr Radda was sworn in. That is N36,938,884,889.88 more than the September 2022 figure, a rise recorded under his predecessor. From there the DMO's tables fall: N33,732,740,995.93 at 30 June 2024, N25,679,586,232.65 at 31 December 2024 and N14,109,376,761.49 at 31 December 2025, the last marked provisional. Measured from N62.37 billion, the fall is N48,265,432,392.83, or 77.38 per cent, which is the governor's N48 billion. Measured from the last figure before he took office, it is N85,204,317,282.71, or 85.79 per cent.

Excerpts from the DMO's table of state domestic debt as at 30 September 2023: title, row 20 Katsina N99,313,694,044.20, and note 4 saying the figures for Katsina, Ogun and Rivers were as at March 31, 2023
Document · Debt Management Office, Domestic Debt Data for the 36 States and the FCT as at September 30, 2023, p.1

Katsina's own books give a different path to a similar end. The Auditor-General's report on the 2025 accounts carries a "Domestic Debt Portfolio Summary 2020 to 2025" on page 140. It puts domestic debt at N47,625,039,214.56 at the end of 2022, N72,215,996,982.47 at the end of 2023 and N75,247,748,990.32 at the end of 2024. In 2023 the Sukuk bond line rose from N8,554,331,927.50 to N31,223,759,807.00, and in 2024 a bridging facility of N18,043,082,742.84 appears. For 2025 the table lists only three amounts: the Sukuk bond at N11,432,725,208.00, contractors' arrears at N1,594,432,880.43 and pension and gratuity arrears at N1,437,018,471.62. They add to N14,464,176,560.05, the same domestic total that Note 26 of the Accountant-General's 2025 financial statements gives on page 56, and N354,799,798.56 more than the DMO's figure for the same date.

Katsina State Domestic Debt Portfolio Summary 2020 to 2025: totals N47,625,039,214.56 for 2022, N72,215,996,982.47 for 2023 and N75,247,748,990.32 for 2024; for 2025 budget support, salary bailout, excess crude loan and bridging facility read 0.00, Sukuk N11,432,725,208.00, contractors' arrears N1,594,432,880.43, pension N1,437,018,471.62, with a printed total of N59,642,836,689.73
Document · Report of the Auditor General on the Accounts of the Government of Katsina State for the Year Ended 31st Dec 2025, p.140

The state's figures and the DMO's do not match before 2025. The DMO's N25.68 billion for the end of 2024 is N49,568,162,757.67 below the N75.25 billion in the state's own table, and the state's books show its domestic debt rising in Mr Radda's first two years while the DMO's figures show it falling. Neither the DMO tables nor the state documents reconcile the two series.

The state's records also show where most of the 2025 fall came from. By its own table, domestic debt fell by N60,783,572,430.27 in the year. Four federal lines that stood at N45,178,660,129.68 at the end of 2024 read 0.00 at the end of 2025: budget support of N11,706,425,969.00, a salary bailout of N7,982,860,163.94, an excess crude oil infrastructure loan of N7,446,291,253.90 and the bridging facility of N18,043,082,742.84. The Auditor-General's notes on page 141 say: "The following 4No. Borrowings have been liquidated by the Federal Government of Nigeria, the loan facilities are hereby stand as liquidated and no more deductions from FAAC". Those four lines are 74.33 per cent of the year's fall. The same notes say the Sukuk bond "decreased with the sum of N10,751,990,000.00" in 2025, 17.69 per cent of the fall, and pension and contractors' arrears fell by N4,364,088,481.28 and N488,833,819.31.

Auditor-General's notes to the debt profile: the Sukuk bond balance fell from N22,184,715,208.00 to N11,432,725,208.00, a decrease of N10,751,990,000.00; note iv says four borrowings, salary bailout, budget support, excess crude oil infrastructural loan and bridging facility, have been liquidated by the Federal Government of Nigeria with no more deductions from FAAC
Document · Report of the Auditor General on the Accounts of the Government of Katsina State for the Year Ended 31st Dec 2025, p.141

The table's own total for 2025 has not caught up with its entries. It prints N59,642,836,689.73, which is N45,178,660,129.68 more than the three amounts listed for that year, exactly the 2024 balances of the four liquidated federal loans. The report's debt profile on page 135 and Note 26 of the financial statements both use N14,464,176,560.05.

The record supports the governor on the numbers. Both figures he gave are in the DMO's tables, his N48 billion is their difference, and the state's own accounts arrive within N355 million of his end point. Measured from the DMO's figure for March 2023, the last before he took office, the fall in his time is larger than the one he claimed. The state did repay debt in 2025, including N10.75 billion of Sukuk bonds, and the end of FAAC deductions for the four federal loans leaves it more of its monthly allocation. What the records do not show is that the whole fall came from the state's own repayments. In the state's books, about three-quarters of the 2025 drop was federal loans that the Auditor-General records as liquidated by the Federal Government.

The revenue claim holds at its end and not at its start. Katsina's 2023 financial statements record tax revenue of N9,576,278,305.94, an average of N798.02 million a month, and non-tax revenue of N7,339,864,191.19. Together that is N16,916,142,497.13, or N1.41 billion a month. The largest single line, personal taxes collected by the Board of Internal Revenue, was N8,347,859,610.46, or N695.65 million a month. Even 2022's tax revenue, N8,219,297,652.61, averaged N684.94 million a month. On each of these measures, monthly revenue in 2023 was above "about N600 million".

For 2026, the state's budget implementation report for the second quarter records independent revenue of N33,138,776,022.04 for January to June, N5.52 billion a month. Tax revenue was N12,867,911,299.19, or N2.14 billion a month, and non-tax revenue N20,270,864,722.84, of which N9,858,231,200.00 came from one line, "sales of reagents & chemicals", booked entirely in the second quarter. Without that line, independent revenue was N3.88 billion a month, still above the governor's N3 billion. On the state's own figures, monthly revenue rose about 3.9 times from 2023 to the first half of 2026, not the five times that N600 million to N3 billion implies.

Set against the DMO's tables, Mr Radda's debt figures hold as stated. Set against his own Auditor-General's report, most of the last year's fall was federal loans that the Auditor-General records as liquidated by the Federal Government, not repayments the state's records show it making. His revenue figure for 2026 holds; his figure for 2023 is lower than the state's accounts. Nothing in these records suggests wrongdoing by anyone.

What this rests on

Documents read: ThisDay, "Katsina Domestic Debt Drops from N62bn to N14bn", 9 October 2026 (saved); DMO, Domestic Debt Data for the 36 States and the FCT as at December 31, 2022 (Katsina row 20 and note 3), March 31, 2023, June 30, 2023 (note 5), September 30, 2023 (note 4), December 31, 2023 (draft, note 4), June 30, 2024, Q4 2024 and December 31, 2025 (provisional); Report of the Auditor General on the Accounts of the Government of Katsina State for the Year Ended 31st Dec 2025, Debt Profile p.135 (PDF p.137), Domestic Debt Portfolio Summary 2020 to 2025 p.140 (PDF p.142), Notes to Debt Profile p.141 (PDF p.143); Katsina State Office of the Accountant General, 2025 Financial Report, Statement of Financial Performance p.6 and Note 26 p.56; 2023 Financial Report, Statement of Financial Performance p.6, Note 3 p.13, Note 26 pp.31 to 32; Katsina State Budget Implementation Report Q2 2026 (July 2026), pp.4 and 12 to 14. Arithmetic re-done (naira). DMO: 62,374,809,154.32 - 14,109,376,761.49 = 48,265,432,392.83; / 62,374,809,154.32 = 77.38%. 99,313,694,044.20 - 62,374,809,154.32 = 36,938,884,889.88. 99,313,694,044.20 - 14,109,376,761.49 = 85,204,317,282.71; / 99,313,694,044.20 = 85.79%. Auditor-General table, 2024: 11,706,425,969.00 + 7,982,860,163.94 + 7,446,291,253.90 + 18,043,082,742.84 + 22,184,715,208.00 + 2,083,266,699.74 + 5,801,106,952.90 = 75,247,748,990.32 (matches printed). 2025 entries: 11,432,725,208.00 + 1,594,432,880.43 + 1,437,018,471.62 = 14,464,176,560.05 (printed total 59,642,836,689.73; difference 45,178,660,129.68). Four federal lines at end-2024: 11,706,425,969.00 + 7,982,860,163.94 + 7,446,291,253.90 + 18,043,082,742.84 = 45,178,660,129.68. Fall in 2025: 75,247,748,990.32 - 14,464,176,560.05 = 60,783,572,430.27 = 45,178,660,129.68 + 10,751,990,000.00 (Sukuk) + 4,364,088,481.28 (pension: 5,801,106,952.90 - 1,437,018,471.62) + 488,833,819.31 (contractors: 2,083,266,699.74 - 1,594,432,880.43). Shares: 45,178,660,129.68 / 60,783,572,430.27 = 74.33%; 10,751,990,000.00 / 60,783,572,430.27 = 17.69%. Sukuk 22,184,715,208.00 - 11,432,725,208.00 = 10,751,990,000.00 (matches note). State vs DMO end-2025: 14,464,176,560.05 - 14,109,376,761.49 = 354,799,798.56; end-2024: 75,247,748,990.32 - 25,679,586,232.65 = 49,568,162,757.67. The printed 2022 and 2023 totals (47,625,039,214.56 and 72,215,996,982.47) exceed their listed entries (47,072,028,093.55 and 72,062,985,860.43) by 553,011,121.01 and 153,011,122.04, which equal the SMEDAN loan balances for 2022 and 2023 in Note 26 of the 2023 financial statements; the table has no SMEDAN row. Revenue: 2023 tax 9,576,278,305.94 / 12 = 798,023,192.16; tax + non-tax 9,576,278,305.94 + 7,339,864,191.19 = 16,916,142,497.13; / 12 = 1,409,678,541.43; KTBIR personal tax line 8,347,859,610.46 / 12 = 695,654,967.54; 2022 tax 8,219,297,652.61 / 12 = 684,941,471.05. H1 2026: tax 12,867,911,299.19 + non-tax 20,270,864,722.84 = 33,138,776,022.03 (printed 33,138,776,022.04); 33,138,776,022.04 / 6 = 5,523,129,337.01; tax / 6 = 2,144,651,883.20; (33,138,776,022.04 - 9,858,231,200.00) / 6 = 3,880,090,803.67; reagents line 29.75% of the half-year; 5,523,129,337.01 / 1,409,678,541.43 = 3.92 times; 3,000,000,000 / 600,000,000 = 5 times. 2025 accounts (context, not in body): tax 21,819,079,573.37 + non-tax 5,409,889,745.40 + IGR returns of parastatals 33,488,252,897.50 = 60,717,222,216.27 (N5.06bn a month), the parastatal returns matched by an equal transfer to revenue-generating MDAs.

What this does not establish

What "liquidated by the Federal Government of Nigeria" means in practice: whether the Federal Government forgave the four loans, repaid them on the state's behalf, offset them against money it owed Katsina, or something else. The Auditor-General's report gives no date, amount paid or federal document, and Vero Record found no federal record naming Katsina's facilities. Why the DMO's figures for Katsina (N99.31bn at March 2023, N25.68bn at end-2024) differ so widely from the state's own (N72.22bn at end-2023, N75.25bn at end-2024); neither side reconciles them, and the DMO's 2024 figures may exclude the federal facilities. Which measure the governor's N600 million a month for 2023 refers to; no revenue line in the 2023 accounts that we checked averages that low. Whether 2026's second-half revenue will keep the first half's pace, given that N9.86bn came from one sales line in one quarter. The 2025 DMO table is provisional. Katsina's foreign debt is outside the claim and this report; Vero Record reported on 29 October that it doubled in 2025. Vero Record did not put these findings to the Katsina State Government before publication. Nothing in these records suggests wrongdoing by anyone.

What we did ourselves

Took the claim from ThisDay's report of 9 October 2026, saved from the newspaper's site. Retrieved the DMO's December 2022 state domestic debt table and read Katsina's row and footnotes in eight DMO quarterly tables from December 2022 to December 2025, noting the reference date the DMO gives for each Katsina figure. Downloaded Katsina's 2023 financial statements and read the 2025 financial statements, the Auditor-General's 2025 report and the second-quarter 2026 budget implementation report. Re-added every column of the Auditor-General's domestic debt table, traced the gaps in its printed totals, split the 2025 fall into its parts, and computed monthly revenue averages from the state's accounts and budget report.

Sources for this report

(A) Debt Management Office, Domestic Debt Data for the 36 States and the FCT as at December 31, 2022 and September 30, 2023 (with the March 2023, June 2023, December 2023, June 2024, Q4 2024 and December 2025 tables); Report of the Auditor General on the Accounts of the Government of Katsina State for the Year Ended 31st Dec 2025, pp.135, 140 and 141; Katsina State Accountant General, 2025 Financial Report, pp.6 and 56, and 2023 Financial Report, pp.6, 13 and 31 to 32; Katsina State Budget Implementation Report Q2 2026, pp.4 and 12 to 14.

Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.

Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.

Corrections

None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.

Investigations editor, Vero Record

Reads the Nigerian public record that others leave unread: budgets, audit reports, court files and registers. Every claim on this page carries the grade of the document behind it, and the report says what that document does not establish.

More on this record