FAAC tables took N650bn for tax refunds to the NRS from May to July revenue; the Budget Office puts the 2026 provision at N150.11bn for the year
Three lines headed "Tax Refund to NRS" in the Accountant-General's FAAC tables took N100bn, N250bn and N300bn from May, June and July 2026 revenue before it was shared. The Budget Office's second-quarter report, posted on 7 November, gives N150.11bn as the 2026 budget for tax refunds for the whole year and records N550bn in the first half. Its second-quarter figure matches the tables exactly. Its first-quarter figure, N200bn, is twice what the tables and its own first-quarter report show.
Before the Federation Account is shared each month, the Accountant-General's tables list everything taken off the top. In the table for May 2026 revenue, shared in June, a line appears that is in none of the six tables for November 2025 to April 2026 revenue: "Tax Refund to NRS", N100,000,000,000.00. The same line reads N250,000,000,000.00 in the table for June revenue and N300,000,000,000.00 in the table for July revenue, shared in August. That is N650 billion in three months set aside as tax refunds through the Nigeria Revenue Service, the former Federal Inland Revenue Service. The Budget Office of the Federation's second-quarter implementation report, posted on 7 November, gives the 2026 budget for tax refunds as N150.11 billion for the whole year. The three deductions come to 4.33 times that amount.
The Budget Office figure is in Table 3.4 on page 24 of the report, "Distributable Revenue as June, 2026". Row 31, "FIRS Tax Refunds", gives N150.11 billion in the column headed "2026 Approved Budget", which the table divides into N37.53 billion a quarter and N75.05 billion a half-year. Against that it records actual refunds of N200.00 billion in the first quarter and N350.00 billion in the second, N550.00 billion for the half-year. That is 3.66 times the provision for the full year and N474.95 billion above the half-year provision, an overrun the table prints as 632.80 per cent. The report's foreword, preface and executive summary do not mention tax refunds; the figures appear only in the table.
The report's quarters follow the month in which revenue was earned, not the month it was shared, and its own cost rows show it. Its second-quarter figure of N180.72 billion for the revenue service's 4 per cent collection cost on company tax and stamp duties equals the N44,013,212,312.05, N54,947,833,641.01 and N81,757,067,969.71 in the Accountant-General's tables for April, May and June revenue, which add to N180,718,113,922.77. Its N89.08 billion for the cost of collecting VAT equals N32,264,680,070.96 + N29,746,706,407.08 + N27,073,007,480.37 = N89,084,393,958.41. On the same months the refunds match too: no tax refund in the April revenue table, N100 billion in May's and N250 billion in June's, which is the report's N350.00 billion exactly. The report did not count the N54,438,414,232.00 the June revenue table returned to the states and the FCT as withholding tax "wrongly remitted to Federation Account", nor the N18,163,078,852.38 deducted every month as "13% Refunds on Subsidy, Priority Projects".
The first quarter does not match. The tables for January, February and March revenue carry one tax refund between them: "Less VAT Refund", N100,000,000,000.00, taken from the VAT column of the March revenue table. The Budget Office's own first-quarter report, posted five days earlier on 2 November, put first-quarter tax refunds at N100.00 billion (Table 3.4, page 22). The second-quarter report prints N200.00 billion for the same quarter without a note, which lowers the quarter's net non-oil revenue from N4,481.80 billion to N4,381.80 billion and its Federation Account main pool from N4,719.27 billion to N4,619.33 billion. Its half-year total of N550 billion is therefore N100 billion more than the N450 billion the Accountant-General's tables show for January to June revenue. The March revenue table also returned N92,840,051,527.90 to the states and the FCT as withholding tax wrongly remitted; on the report's own treatment of the June return that is not a tax refund, and adding it would give N192.84 billion, not N200 billion.
Measured against collections, the refunds are far larger than the budget assumed. The approved column's N150.11 billion is 0.52 per cent of the N29,049.31 billion of gross non-oil revenue the same table budgets for the year. The report's N550 billion of first-half refunds is 4.88 per cent of the N11,269.92 billion of gross non-oil revenue it records for January to June. Spread evenly, the year's provision allows N12.51 billion a month; the N300 billion taken from July revenue alone is almost exactly twice the provision for the whole year, or 23.98 months of it.
The deductions have continued past the period the report covers. In the table for July revenue, the N300 billion refund is the third-largest amount taken before sharing, after N520 billion to the Non-Oil Excess Revenue Account and N500 billion to the National Security Emergency Fund, and ahead of N259 billion for the Infrastructure Development Fund to States and N200 billion to the Nigeria Sovereign Investment Authority. With the N100 billion VAT refund from March revenue, the four refund lines from March to July revenue add to N750 billion, N0.55 billion short of five times the year's provision. The Accountant-General's publication page, checked on 9 November, has no table yet for August revenue. The committee's communique for that month, released on 17 September, puts "Transfers, Intervention and Refunds" at N1.221 trillion without itemising them.
Because the refunds are taken before the money is divided, all three tiers of government carry them. The three "Tax Refund to NRS" lines sit in the Statutory column, which the same tables share 52.68 per cent to the Federal Government, 26.72 per cent to the states and 20.60 per cent to local councils. On that formula, N650 billion taken before sharing is about N342.42 billion of federal money, N173.68 billion of state money and N133.90 billion of council money. The N100 billion VAT refund came out of the VAT pool, which the 2026 tables share 10, 55 and 35 per cent, so about N90 billion of it would otherwise have gone to states and councils. These are Vero Record's calculations on the published formula; the tables do not apportion the refunds themselves.
The government expected refunds to rise, though the documents do not show it expected this much. Its 2026-2028 Medium-Term Expenditure Framework says refund projections "were made based on the number and amount of refund applications received and processed in the last 2 years", along with exchange rates, inflation and "taxpayers who are perpetually in refund position by virtue of legislations" (page 27). On page 26 it notes that the Nigeria Tax Act 2025 lets taxpayers claim input VAT on services and fixed assets, "previously disallowed", and says: "This will likely increase VAT refund claims". A refund returns tax that a business or a person has overpaid, and a rise in refunds can follow from new tax rules working as intended. The documents do not say which taxes the 2026 refunds relate to; the three NRS lines are in the Statutory column, not the VAT column.
On the months it covers, the Budget Office's second-quarter refund figure agrees with the Accountant-General's tables, and so do its collection-cost rows for both quarters: the first-quarter N101.84 billion and N96.64 billion equal N101,843,641,801.93 and N96,641,432,017.79 in the tables for January to March revenue. The tables themselves add up. Re-added, the Statutory column of the June revenue table comes to N3,450,950,588,357.11 and that of the July revenue table to N4,359,038,182,739.25, the totals printed, with each refund inside them; the May revenue table is within one kobo of its printed total. The refunds are named in published documents, not netted out of sight.
The documents do not show who received the refunds, for which taxes or years, how the amounts were approved, whether the Nigeria Revenue Service has paid them out, or why each is a round sum of N100 billion, N250 billion or N300 billion. They do not explain why the second-quarter report doubles its first-quarter refund figure. Nothing in them suggests wrongdoing by anyone, and none is alleged. The Budget Office, the Accountant-General's office and the Nigeria Revenue Service were not asked for comment before publication; the figures above are their own, set against each other.
What this rests on
Budget Office of the Federation, Second Quarter 2026 Budget Implementation Report (56 pages, file 'Second Quarter 2026 Budget Implementation Report.pdf', created 6 November 2026, posted 7 November 2026), downloaded from budgetoffice.gov.ng on 9 November 2026 and read for this report: Table 3.4, printed p.24 (PDF p.40), rows 23 to 41; foreword p.i, preface pp.ii to v and executive summary pp.xii to xv; the whole text searched for 'refund' (no hits outside Table 3.4). Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, FAAC disbursement reports, Table I, for revenue of November 2025 (shared December 2025) and December 2025 to July 2026 (shared January to August 2026): copies downloaded by Vero Record from oagf.gov.ng in October 2026 and re-read; on 9 November 2026 the live April, May, June, July and August 2026 files had exactly the same byte sizes (4,589,328; 4,086,220; 3,646,263; 4,104,767; 3,641,130). Every page of the January to August 2026 reports was searched for 'refund'. Budget Office, 2026 First Quarter Budget Implementation Report (created 2 November 2026), Table 3.4, printed p.22; 2026-2028 MTEF/FSP, printed pp.26 to 27; both re-read from Vero Record's earlier downloads. FAAC communique for August 2026 revenue as released on fmino.gov.ng, 17 September 2026. Arithmetic re-done: NRS refunds 100,000,000,000.00 + 250,000,000,000.00 + 300,000,000,000.00 = N650bn; 650 / 150.11 = 4.33; with the March 'Less VAT Refund' 100 + 650 = N750bn; 750 / 150.11 = 4.996; 5 x 150.11 = 750.55, so 0.55 short. BIR row 31: 150.11 / 4 = 37.53 and / 2 = 75.05 (printed); 200.00 + 350.00 = 550.00; 550 / 150.11 = 3.66; 550 - 75.05 = 474.95; 474.95 / 75.055 = 632.80 per cent (printed). Period check, second quarter: NRS 4% cost 44,013,212,312.05 + 54,947,833,641.01 + 81,757,067,969.71 = 180,718,113,922.77 (BIR 180.72); VAT cost 32,264,680,070.96 + 29,746,706,407.08 + 27,073,007,480.37 = 89,084,393,958.41 (BIR 89.08); refunds 0 + 100 + 250 = 350 (BIR 350.00). First quarter: 44,163,848,419.37 + 26,737,152,540.14 + 30,942,640,842.42 = 101,843,641,801.93 (BIR 101.84); 43,326,423,341.76 + 26,738,012,784.43 + 26,576,995,891.60 = 96,641,432,017.79 (BIR 96.64); refunds 0 + 0 + 100 = 100 (Q1 BIR 100.00; Q2 BIR 200.00). Half-year: 100 + 100 + 250 = 450 against BIR 550, difference 100. 100 + 92.84 = 192.84. Restatement: 4,481.80 - 4,381.80 = 100.00; 4,719.27 - 4,619.33 = 99.94; 2,185.29 - 2,085.34 = 99.95 (rounding). Days: 2 November to 7 November 2026 = 5 days. Scale: 150.11 / 29,049.31 = 0.52 per cent; 550 / 11,269.92 = 4.88 per cent; 150.11 / 12 = 12.51 a month; 300 / 12.509 = 23.98 months; 300 / 150.11 = 1.999. Shares: May revenue table FGN 749,801,586,689.97, states 380,309,384,896.66, LGCs 293,202,594,643.38 = 52.68, 26.72 and 20.60 per cent; 650 x 0.5268 = 342.42, x 0.2672 = 173.68, x 0.2060 = 133.90, total 650.00; March revenue VAT shares 51,539,033,986.99 / 283,464,686,928.46 / 180,386,618,954.48 = 10.00 / 55.00 / 35.00 per cent; 100 x 0.90 = 90. Table totals re-added: June revenue Statutory column (16 rows) = 3,450,950,588,357.11; July revenue (15 rows) = 4,359,038,182,739.25; May revenue (13 rows) = 2,651,718,906,323.52 against 2,651,718,906,323.51 printed. July revenue table, amounts taken before sharing in order: 520 (Non-Oil Excess Revenue Account), 500 (National Security Emergency Fund), 300 (Tax Refund to NRS), 259 (Infrastructure Development Fund to States), 200 (NSIA), 108 (Intervention for State Security), 99.39 (NRS cost of collection).
What this does not establish
Who received the refunds, for which taxes, taxpayers or years, how they were approved, and whether the Nigeria Revenue Service has paid them out; the tables give only one line a month. Why the amounts are round sums. Which first-quarter figure is right, N100.00bn or N200.00bn, and why the second-quarter report changed it; the report gives no note. Whether the N150.11bn in the Budget Office's '2026 Approved Budget' column appears in any other approved document; it was not found in the 2026-2028 MTEF text, and the 2026 Appropriation Act authorises spending rather than Federation Account deductions. The legal basis and approval process for deducting refunds from the Federation Account were not examined; the Nigeria Tax Administration Act 2025 was not read. How much was refunded in 2025, and whether the refunds will continue at this rate; the table for August 2026 revenue is not yet published, and the 17 September communique does not itemise its N1.221 trillion of transfers, interventions and refunds. The split of the burden between federal, state and council governments is Vero Record's arithmetic on the sharing formula, not a figure in the tables. Nothing in the documents suggests wrongdoing by anyone, and none is alleged. The Budget Office, the Office of the Accountant-General and the Nigeria Revenue Service were not asked for comment.
What we did ourselves
Downloaded the Budget Office's second-quarter 2026 report two days after it was posted and read Table 3.4 line by line. Matched its quarters to revenue months by re-adding its collection-cost rows against the Accountant-General's monthly Table I, which showed that the report's quarters follow the month revenue was earned. Searched every page of the eight 2026 FAAC reports for refund lines, re-added three Statutory columns, and set the refunds against the report's own budget column, against the report's first-quarter edition of 2 November and against gross non-oil revenue. Computed the share each tier of government would have received on the published sharing formula. Read the 2026-2028 framework's own explanation of how refunds were projected.
Sources for this report
(A) Budget Office of the Federation, Second Quarter 2026 Budget Implementation Report, Table 3.4 'Distributable Revenue as June, 2026', row 31 'FIRS Tax Refunds' (p.24); Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation, FAAC disbursement reports, Table I, for March, May, June and July 2026 revenue (shared April, June, July and August 2026), rows 'Less VAT Refund' and 'Tax Refund to NRS'.
- Second Quarter 2026 Budget Implementation Report (56 pages) · Budget Office of the Federation, Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning · 7 November 2026
- Second Quarter 2026 Budget Implementation Report (publication page) · Budget Office of the Federation · 7 November 2026
- FAAC Disbursement, April 2026 (March 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · April 2026 (file dated 25 June 2026)
- FAAC Disbursement, May 2026 (April 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · May 2026 (file dated 25 June 2026)
- FAAC Disbursement, June 2026 (May 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · June 2026 (file dated 6 August 2026)
- FAAC Disbursement, July 2026 (June 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · July 2026 (file dated 20 October 2026)
- FAAC Disbursement, August 2026 (July 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · August 2026 (file dated 20 October 2026)
- FAAC Disbursement, March 2026 (February 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · March 2026
- FAAC Disbursement, February 2026 (January 2026 revenue) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · February 2026
- FAAC reports (publication page, checked 9 November 2026) · Office of the Accountant-General of the Federation · 9 November 2026
- 2026 First Quarter Budget Implementation Report · Budget Office of the Federation · 2 November 2026
- 2026-2028 Medium-Term Expenditure Framework and Fiscal Strategy Paper · Budget Office of the Federation, Ministry of Budget and Economic Planning · December 2025
- FG, States And LGCs Share N2.338 Trillion From N3.685 Trillion Gross Revenue For August 2026 (FAAC communique) · Federal Ministry of Information and National Orientation · 17 September 2026
- FG retained N1.1trn from May FAAC revenue, Dele Oye says deductions weaken fiscal federalism · The Nigeria Lawyer · 23 June 2026
- File:Revenue house Abuja 06.jpg · Wikimedia Commons (Jummy001, CC BY-SA 4.0) · 30 July 2026
Confidence: high. This is our own assessment of whether the event occurred as described, separate from the grade, which describes what kind of thing the claim rests on.
Not obtained: where the underlying document is named above but not linked, we did not hold a copy at the time of publication. We purchase nothing and request nothing in our own name.
Corrections
None on this report. If you find an error, it will be published here, at the same length, with the date it was found, and the original wording will remain visible above it.
